The Inpatient looks and sounds the part, then moves too slowly to scare
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A VR detour between Until Dawn and the anthology years
The Inpatient is the PlayStation VR horror game Supermassive Games put out in January 2018, three years after Until Dawn. By then the studio's catalog also included Until Dawn: Rush of Blood (2016) and Hidden Agenda (2017), and Bravo Team followed later the same year. Sony Interactive Entertainment published it for PlayStation 4, and it needs the headset.
It came out on January 23, 2018 in North America and a day later in Europe. It runs on Unreal Engine 4 and is rated Mature 17+. It isn't part of a series, so it stands or falls on its own terms. Critics mostly decided it landed somewhere in the middle.
What changed: you're the patient, and you talk
The biggest change is the camera. This is first-person survival horror built for a headset, so the player isn't watching a cast from a distance. You play a patient with amnesia inside the Blackwood Sanatorium in 1952, in the aftermath of a collapse underground, trying to get your memories back.
The second change is your voice. Characters react to what you say out loud through voice recognition, instead of only to buttons. On paper that's a smart fit for VR horror: speaking to someone in the room is more intimate than picking a line from a menu, and the setup of a confused patient being questioned gives the feature a natural reason to exist.
Awards juries saw something in it. The game earned nominations at the National Academy of Video Game Trade Reviewers Awards for Control Design, VR and Direction in Virtual Reality, which suggests the headset-and-voice design was more than a gimmick.
What stays at the center: the ending bends to your choices
Under the new presentation, the core idea is consequence. The outcome of the story depends entirely on the decisions the player makes. That's the hook meant to pull you back for another run, and it's the main thing the game asks you to do.
That's also where the weakness shows. If decisions are the main verb, everything between them has to hold your attention, and critics often said it doesn't. A lack of variety in what you actually do was one of the most common complaints. A horror game can get away with few mechanics if it keeps the pressure on, but a slow pace takes away that cover.
Critics liked the room more than the walk through it
Reception was polarized. Metacritic put it at 59, which it labels "mixed or average," from 55 reviews. The other aggregates show how much opinion varied:
- 71/100 from 12 reviews of the PlayStation 4 version
- 60/100 from 50 reviews, from an outlet whose second measure across 49 reviews was just 15%
- 42/100 from 5 reviews
That 15% next to a 60 is the clearest sign of the split. Plenty of reviewers gave it a passing grade, but few were ready to recommend it.
The praise was consistent: critics singled out the presentation and atmosphere. Industry awards backed that up, especially on sound. It was nominated for Sound Design at the 2018 Develop Awards, for Best Audio Design and Visual Design at The Independent Game Developers' Association Awards 2018, and for Sound Mixing in Virtual Reality at the National Academy of Video Game Trade Reviewers Awards.
A sanatorium that sounds this good only needs something to do inside it. Critics kept saying it didn't have enough.
The criticism was just as consistent: the slow pace and the narrow range of play. Taken together, The Inpatient comes across as a strong place to be and a weak game to play. If you came for the mood, that may be enough; if you came for the scares, it probably won't be.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Inpatient en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q30277535 wikidata.org