Analysis · Uncharted: Legacy of Thieves Collection

Uncharted's treasure hunt through real history, on PlayStation 5 and Windows

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A treasure hunt that runs through real history

Uncharted is built on one idea: a small crew of treasure hunters travels the world to solve historical mysteries. The series mixes historical fiction with fantasy and folklore, and it puts made-up characters next to real historical figures and events. Most of what critics praised grows out of that premise, so it's the right test for this collection.

Legacy of Thieves Collection is a single-player action-adventure game from Naughty Dog and Iron Galaxy Studios, published by Sony Interactive Entertainment. It came out worldwide on PlayStation 5 on January 28, 2022, and on Windows later that year. In the main series you play as Nathan Drake. In the expansion you play as Chloe Frazer.

The premise works because of who's chasing the treasure

A treasure hunt is only as good as the people on it, and that's where critics aimed most of their praise. Across the series, reviewers singled out the writing and voice acting along with the graphics. Nathan Drake became popular enough to be seen as a PlayStation mascot.

The awards tell the same story. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End won Best Narrative and Best Performance at The Game Awards 2016 and Best Game at the 13th British Academy Games Awards. It also won more Game of the Year awards than any other game that year. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy, from 2017, won two categories at the National Academy of Video Game Trade Reviewers Awards and the People's Voice award for Best Music/Sound Design at the Webby Awards.

That track record is the main reason to pay attention to a collection led by Drake and Chloe Frazer. The series earned its reputation on characters people wanted to follow, more than on the treasure itself.

Critics agreed, and the scores barely move

The critic scores for this collection are unusually close together:

  • 87/100 averaged across 149 reviews, as of November 4, 2022
  • 87/100 from a smaller set of 8 reviews
  • 8/10 in a review of the Windows version published October 18, 2022

When 149 reviews average 87 and a smaller set lands on the same number, critics broadly agreed. The critic average of 8.7 is calculated from those critic averages, not from anyone at GameRaven playing it.

The visuals matter for a premise about faraway places, and the series has a strong record there. Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception won Best Graphics at the 2011 Spike Video Game Awards, plus awards for visual engineering, art direction and animation at the 15th Annual Interactive Achievement Awards. The one listed Windows review came in slightly under the overall average, so Windows players should expect a version critics rated well, though a little below the consensus.

Where the big idea doesn't tell you much

Treasure hunters chasing history is a story premise. The record says little about how the game actually plays, so the critic scores alone can't tell you how the combat, climbing or puzzles feel. Critics praised the series for its story, performances and visuals, and those are the strengths you can count on.

Some practical limits:

  • It's single-player only. No other mode is listed.
  • It's rated Teen in one rating system and PEGI 16 in another, so parents of younger teens should check which rating applies where they live.
  • It's on PlayStation 5 and Windows only.

If what draws you to a game is a well-acted story set against real history and folklore, the critics' consensus suits you. If you mainly want deep systems to master, nothing critics wrote about this series promises that.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet