Scores
Most played on Steam
496 games among most played on Steam, each with its score and a critics' overview written from the published record. How the overviews are written.
- Phantom Blade Zero 2026Phantom Blade Zero rewards players who read every enemy swingA wuxia action RPG built around parries, color-coded threats and a 66-day clock, and critics broadly liked what S-Game made.8.8
- Forza Horizon 6 2026Forza Horizon 6 moves a proven racing formula to Japan and polishes it hardCritics found the series' best map yet in a stylized Japan, with a familiar structure and a story most of them wanted to skip.9.1
- Crimson Desert 2026Crimson Desert is a huge combat sandbox with a story that can't keep upCritics praised Pearl Abyss's open world and fights, but the story, the controls and a cramped inventory pulled it back to good, not great.7.8
- EA Sports FC 27 2026EA Sports FC 27 rebuilds career mode's transfer market and splits criticsCritics rated the fourth EA Sports FC game generally favorable, but only 68% recommended it, and the new features show why.7.7
- ARC Raiders 2025ARC Raiders makes losing your loot thrilling, best enjoyed with a squadA tense third-person extraction shooter that critics called the best way into the genre, with rough edges for solo players and controller users.8.7
- Battlefield 6 2025Battlefield 6 wins critics with its multiplayer and loses them on its campaignCritics liked Battlefield 6's big, destructible multiplayer. They called its single-player story safe and easy to forget.8.3
- EA Sports FC 26 2025FC 26 gives online play and Career Mode their own kind of footballEA Vancouver's third FC game runs on two rule sets, one for competitive play and one for realism, and critics mostly liked the result.8.0
- Elden Ring Nightreign 2025Nightreign squeezes Elden Ring into three in-game days and a closing circleFromSoftware's co-op roguelike spin-off turns Limgrave into a shrinking three-day race, and critics mostly liked the result.8.0
- Doom: The Dark Ages 2025The Doom Slayer slows down to a shield-first brawl, and critics split on itCritics agreed id Software's heavier, slower Doom is good. They argued over whether it's a bold turn or a safe one.8.6
- Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 2025Expedition 33 pairs acclaimed parry combat with a world critics found flatCritics loved the timed-parry combat, the story about grief and the score. Most of the complaints were about the world between fights.9.2
- The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Remastered 2025Oblivion Remastered looks the part but still runs badly on PCCritics praised a full Unreal Engine 5 rebuild with both expansions included, but its performance problems outlasted Bethesda's patches.8.3
- The First Berserker: Khazan 2025Khazan's stamina duels thrill some critics and wear others downA Soulslike built on draining stamina, with boss fights critics loved and levels they mostly didn't, set in the Dungeon & Fighter universe.8.1
- Split Fiction 2025Split Fiction is a two-player game first, and critics loved it that wayHazelight's sci-fi and fantasy co-op adventure drew near-universal praise, but you can only play it with a partner.9.1
- Monster Hunter Wilds 2025Monster Hunter Wilds keeps World's 14 weapons and trades away some of its biteCapcom's follow-up to Monster Hunter: World adds open biomes, a mount and a real story, and critics loved it while debating how easy it got.8.9
- Civilization VII 2025Civilization VII splits history into three ages, and critics split with itFiraxis kept the series' turn-by-turn pull and rebuilt diplomacy, but its age resets and mid-game civilization swaps divided critics and players.7.9
- Kingdom Come: Deliverance II 2025Deliverance II is a stubborn medieval sim that critics mostly fell forWarhorse's first-person sequel drew near-universal praise for its systems and looks. The one cooler verdict shows who will love how much it asks.9.0
- Dynasty Warriors: Origins 2025Origins gives every weapon its own moves and wins most critics backOmega Force's tenth Dynasty Warriors rebuilds its combat around one hero and his troops; most critics loved it, but one called it stuck in the past.8.1
- Marvel Rivals 2024Marvel Rivals turns 54 free heroes and breakable maps into a 6v6 brawlNetEase's free hero shooter won critics over with fair monetization and a huge roster, but surrender votes and chat censorship drew fire.7.9
- S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2: Heart of Chornobyl 2024S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 drew six million players despite a rough technical launchA survival shooter that rewards patience and scores 74/100 with critics, held back by technical issues its own studio promised to fix.7.5
- Farming Simulator 25 2024Farming Simulator 25 rewards patience with real machines and a slow grindCritics praise the series' calm and its realistic machinery, but call the same work repetitive. Which one you notice decides whether this is for you.7.2
- Dragon Age: The Veilguard 2024Veilguard trades tactics for combos and leans on a cast critics lovedBioWare's fourth Dragon Age is a faster, friendlier action RPG with standout companions and a story that critics found much weaker.8.1
- Metaphor: ReFantazio 2024Persona's calendar and dungeons, rebuilt around a fantasy electionAtlus fans get the day-planning, bond-building role-playing game they know, with a sharper political story that critics rated among 2024's best.9.3
- Dragon Ball: Sparking! Zero 2024A huge Dragon Ball brawler that critics split on for depthSpike Chunsoft's revival of the Budokai Tenkaichi format won strong praise for its fan service and drew doubts about how deep its fighting goes.8.1
- Silent Hill 2 2024Silent Hill 2 keeps its grief story whole and lets the fights wobbleBloober Team's remake won critics over with its story, fog and sound, while its deliberately clumsy combat and backtracking split them.8.7
- EA Sports FC 25 2024EA Sports FC 25 won a Game Awards trophy and still split its criticsThe 32nd EA Sports football game scored 77/100 on Metacritic, but only 63% of critics on OpenCritic recommended it.7.7
- Frostpunk 2 2024Frostpunk 2 asks you to keep a frozen city alive by winning its votes11 Bit Studios moved the series from heating a camp to governing a crowded city, and critic aggregates landed at 85 to 86 out of 100.8.6
- Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine II 2024Space Marine II rewards charging in, and critics mostly agreedExecutions refill your armor, friends revive you, and 85% of 168 critics recommended this aggressive co-op brawler.8.3
- NBA 2K25 2024NBA 2K25 scored well with critics, but only about half came out clearly for itCritics rated NBA 2K25 as a solid basketball sim, but its online servers shut down on December 31, 2026, and that now outweighs the scores.7.6
- Black Myth: Wukong 2024Wukong rewards boss hunters and won't lower its bar for anyone elseGame Science's Soulslike take on the Sun Wukong legend earns 81 to 82 from critics and gives build tinkerers plenty to work with.8.2
- Zenless Zone Zero 2024Zenless Zone Zero's flashy team fights split critics on how deep they goCritics praised the style and the character roster, but split on whether the swap-and-parry combat has depth or is just clicking.7.4
- Nine Sols 2024Nine Sols makes the deflect the engine of every fightRed Candle Games follows Detention and Devotion with a taopunk 2D action-platformer that critics rated as hard, inventive and well worth the effort.8.7
- Hades II 2024Supergiant's first sequel gives Hades two roads and a sharper heroineHades II splits its runs between the Underworld and the surface, adds magic and Hexes, and stumbled only at its ending.9.5
- Dragon's Dogma II 2024Dragon's Dogma II gets its best moments from things nobody scriptedCritics praised an open world where emergent events and AI Pawns create the stories. Performance, ally AI and paid extras drew the complaints.8.7
- Balatro 2024Balatro turns poker hands into a scoring puzzle few critics could put downA solo developer's poker-themed roguelike deck-builder that won near-universal praise for its approachable rules and deep runs.9.3
- Helldivers 2 2024Helldivers 2 rewards squads who can laugh at their own friendly fireA four-player co-op shooter with no solo campaign, a sharp satirical streak and a live-service history almost as loud as its firefights.8.5
- Persona 3 Reload 2024Persona 3 Reload rebuilds a 2006 classic with Persona 5's comfortsAtlus remade Persona 3 with modern menus, maps and dorm life. Critics loved the result, though the remake leaves some older content out.8.8
- Tekken 8 2024Tekken 8 rewards attacking, and most critics rewarded it backCritics rank it near the top of the series but split on whether its aggressive Heat system and thin offline menu welcome new players.8.9
- Enshrouded 2024Enshrouded turns a deadly fog into the best reason to build with friendsA survival action RPG for co-op crews that cares more about fighting and building than about tending hunger meters.8.3
- Palworld 2024Palworld puts its captured monsters to work, and critics split on the jokePocketpair's survival game turns creature collecting into a labor system. The fights and the base-building loop drew praise; critics disagreed on the humor.7.2
- Age of Mythology: Retold 2024Age of Mythology returns with a smarter interface and a plainer faceCritics liked the clearer UI, rebuilt soundtrack and quality-of-life changes in this 2002 remake, but some missed the old art and hit pathfinding bugs.8.2
- Warhammer 40,000: Rogue Trader 2023Rogue Trader hands you a space empire and makes every order countOwlcat's turn-based Warhammer 40,000 RPG won critics over with its writing and its choices, and lost some of them to launch bugs.7.8
- Cities: Skylines II 2023A city builder five times bigger than its predecessor, and slower for itCities: Skylines II bets everything on scale and a deeper simulation. Critics liked the systems, but launch performance kept getting in the way.7.7
- Lords of the Fallen 2023Lords of the Fallen pairs a clever second world with uneven footingHexWorks' 2023 reboot pairs a lantern that opens the land of the dead with combat critics liked and a world they found hard to care about.7.0
- Forza Motorsport 2023Forza Motorsport bets everything on the circuit, and mostly winsTurn 10's reboot drives better than any Motorsport game before it, critics said, but it has fewer cars and tracks, and its progression split reviewers.8.5
- EA SPORTS FC™ 24 2023EA Sports FC 24 keeps FIFA's football and pushes Ultimate Team harderThe first EA Sports FC game adds PlayStyles, Evolutions and women's players to a familiar base, plus some of the series' worst pack sales.7.7
- Payday 3 2023Payday 3 has strong heists, too few of them and a rough online launchCritics liked the cooperative robberies in Payday 3, but thin content and days of server outages at launch held it back.6.4
- Party Animals 2023Party Animals wins critics with puppy brawls but lost players over skinsCritics praised the floppy physics fights and bright visuals, while Steam players at launch turned on the pricing and a missing offline mode.7.8
- Lies of P 2023Lies of P turns Pinocchio's lying into a Soulslike's sharpest ideaCritics praised the bosses, the weapon crafting and the Belle Époque city of Krat, and split on whether it stands apart from Bloodborne.8.1
- Mortal Kombat 1 2023Mortal Kombat 1 is a strong reboot on PC and consoles, but not on SwitchNetherRealm's 2023 reboot adds tag-in Kameo Fighters and rollback netcode, and critics liked it everywhere except the Switch.8.0
- NBA 2K24 2023NBA 2K24 plays like real basketball, then charges you for everything around itCritics praised the on-court feel and the ProPLAY animations, but aggressive microtransactions and a shut-down online side sink it.6.6
- Sea of Stars 2023Sea of Stars has dazzling pixel art and a story you can see comingSabotage Studio's 2023 turn-based RPG won critics over with its pixel art, music and lock-breaking fights, even as its plot left several of them cold.8.9
- Armored Core VI: Fires of Rubicon 2023Armored Core VI turns every fight into a puzzle you solve in the garageFromSoftware's mech series reboot won critics over with fast combat and a parts system that rewards rebuilding your machine after every loss.8.0
- Remnant 2 2023Remnant 2 rerolls its bosses, quests and story, and its gunplay holds it upGunfire Games' soulslike shooter randomizes far more than its maps. Critics loved the combat and the shuffle but were cooler on the story.8.3
- F1 23 2023F1 23 earned rare agreement from critics by changing how the cars driveCodemasters overhauled the handling, brought back red flags and wrote a better story mode, and critics broadly agreed it beat F1 22.8.5
- Diablo IV 2023Diablo IV keeps the series' loot formula and swaps kings for ordinary peopleThe fourth main Diablo game is darker and more grounded than Diablo III, though critics found its dungeons repetitive and its skill trees thinner.8.7
- Street Fighter 6 2023Street Fighter 6 makes every exchange a decision about one shared meterCapcom's 2023 fighter puts a single Drive Gauge at the center of every exchange, and critics agreed it gives each round a sharp risk-and-reward edge.9.1
- The Outlast Trials 2023The Outlast Trials makes helplessness a team sport, and pays a priceRed Barrels turns Outlast's no-fight horror into graded co-op trials with upgrades, and critics mostly approved.7.5
- Age of Wonders 4 2023Age of Wonders 4 is a fantasy 4X built around factions you design yourselfA turn-based strategy game for players who love the setup screen, with deep faction building, reworked battles and a thin story campaign.8.2
- Dredge 2023Dredge turns a calm fishing loop into a nightly gamble with the darkCritics loved Dredge's art, its cargo puzzle and its creeping dread, and split on whether the fishing itself holds up over a full run.8.4
- Resident Evil 4 2023Resident Evil 4 adds a breakable parrying knife and keeps the old dreadCapcom's 2023 remake lets Leon shoot on the move, gives Ashley a real role and keeps the village siege that critics still rank highest.8.8
- Star Wars Jedi: Survivor 2023Respawn's Star Wars sequel turns parries and wall-runs into a richer gameRespawn's 2023 sequel won critics over with tough lightsaber fights and dense maps, but its PC version was widely panned for poor performance.8.1
- Atomic Heart 2023Atomic Heart builds a robot utopia, then hands you the wreckage to fight withCritics praised the ambition and imagination of Mundfish's Soviet shooter, but its combat, writing and fetch quests split the room.7.4
- Undisputed 2023Undisputed nails boxing's look and roster but critics found the punches missSteel City Interactive's boxing sim has real licensed fighters and smart footwork, but hit detection, online play and paid DLC drew critics' complaints.7.1
- Starfield 2023Starfield's 1,000 planets split critics more than its story didBethesda's space role-playing game drew favorable reviews, but critics and players disagreed sharply over how its exploration and main story hold together.7.9
- Need for Speed Unbound 2022Need for Speed Unbound scored best on console and weakest on PCCriterion's return to the series earned solid console reviews, a cooler reception on PC, and a risk-heavy loop that puts a whole week's winnings on the line.7.4
- Warhammer 40,000: Darktide 2022Darktide's four-player combat outclasses the loot grind built around itFatshark's co-op shooter took its Vermintide 2 formula into Warhammer 40,000, and critics praised the fighting but not the gear economy around it.7.6
- God of War Ragnarök 2022Ragnarök gives 2018 fans more of what worked, then talks over its puzzlesSanta Monica Studio's Norse finale adds bigger worlds, a new spear and a reworked shield, but critics found the core loop barely changed.9.1
- Dave the Diver 2022Dave the Diver turns each day's catch into a night of sushi serviceMintrocket's pixel art adventure ties deep-sea dives to a sushi bar, and critics found that each half keeps the other going.8.8
- Victoria 3 2022Victoria 3 runs a gripping economy, but its wars stay fiddlyParadox's 1836 to 1936 strategy sequel won critics over with its economic simulation. Its war system and late-game routine drew the complaints.8.3
- Astlibra Revision 2022Astlibra Revision starts slow, then wins critics over with its combat and castA 16-year solo project that critics called mundane at first and captivating later, with combat nearly every reviewer praised.8.2
- Overwatch 2022Overwatch cut a tank from each team, and it plays faster for itBlizzard's free-to-play hero shooter moved to five-on-five to speed up its fights. Critics liked the pace. The store is still the weak spot.7.7
- FIFA 23 2022FIFA 23 closes out the series with slick football and familiar frustrationsCritics called the last FIFA's matches slick and dramatic, but they also found it too close to last year and too eager to sell you an edge.7.6
- NBA 2K23 2022NBA 2K23 drew award buzz from critics and pay-to-win anger from playersCritics rated Visual Concepts' 2022 basketball game well, but complaints about its VC costs and its 2024 server shutdown change the case for buying it now.8.0
- The Last of Us Part I 2022Naughty Dog's remake of The Last of Us rebuilds everything except the storyNaughty Dog's 2022 remake keeps the 2013 script word for word and remakes the faces, enemies, controls and accessibility around it.8.0
- Cult of the Lamb 2022Cult of the Lamb makes running a sacrificial cult feel strangely cozyMassive Monster's roguelike drew wide praise for its cult management and art, while critics split sharply over whether its fights are fluid or a mess.8.4
- Stray 2022Stray's cat carries the game, even when its puzzles forget it's a catCritics loved playing as a cat in a neon robot city. The fetch quests and the Zurk chases were where opinion split.8.3
- My Time at Sandrock 2022Sandrock makes water the rule of a cozy desert town rebuildA farm life sim RPG about fixing up a desert town. Critics liked the loop and the people more than the combat or the Switch version.7.6
- V Rising 2022V Rising turns a vampire's weaknesses into the rules of a survival gameStunlock Studios moved from Battlerite to an open-world survival game where sunlight, garlic and blood shape every outing and every castle wall.8.2
- Warhammer 40,000: Chaos Gate - Daemonhunters 2022Turn-based squad tactics against a plague, with critics in steady agreementA turn-based Warhammer 40,000 tactics game that critics scored between 76 and 80, and that earned a D.I.C.E. nomination for strategy.7.8
- Lego Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga 2022The Skywalker Saga turns nine films into one galaxy you can roamCritics loved the open planets and the funny story levels in this Lego take on all nine films, even where its size left some content thin.8.1
- Tiny Tina's Wonderlands 2022Tiny Tina's Wonderlands trades grenades for spells and lets you mix two classesGearbox's fantasy spin-off on Borderlands adds melee, spells and dual classes, though critics found some old Borderlands 3 problems still in place.7.8
- The Planet Crafter 2022The Planet Crafter turns a dead world green one machine at a timeA survival game about filling a barren planet with air, heat and life. Critics loved how it builds, though the start is thin and the ending is light.7.8
- Core Keeper 2022Core Keeper takes familiar survival crafting underground, and it worksCritics found that digging outward from one glowing chamber makes a well-worn sandbox loop feel new, though the material grind wears on some.8.5
- Midnight Suns 2022Midnight Suns plays its best hand in battle and folds at the AbbeyFiraxis Games built card-driven tactics that critics loved. The hours spent befriending heroes between fights split them.8.3
- Elden Ring 2022Elden Ring's open world earned its acclaim, but its PC port and menus didn'tCritics praised FromSoftware's open world for rewarding every detour. Their complaints went to menus, PC framerates and a cryptic story.9.3
- Horizon Forbidden West 2022Horizon Forbidden West turns every machine fight into a puzzle of partsGuerrilla Games' 2022 sequel sends Aloy west with a bigger arsenal and a gorgeous world, plus a story critics found harder to follow.8.8
- Total War: Warhammer III 2022Warhammer III forces more battles and gives its campaign a tenser endgameCreative Assembly's third Warhammer strategy game won critics over with its demonic realms and new factions, though a harsher auto-resolve tested some.8.6
- Sifu 2022Sifu turns every death into lost years, and that's why it worksSloclap's kung fu revenge brawler kept the beat 'em up's fists and changed what failing costs. Most critics said the trade pays off.7.9
- Dying Light 2 Stay Human 2022Dying Light 2 builds a better parkour city and a weaker story to run through itTechland's 2022 sequel quadruples the map and sharpens the free-running, but critics found its night tamer and its script hard to sit through.7.8
- Uncharted: Legacy of Thieves Collection 2022Uncharted's treasure hunt through real history, on PlayStation 5 and WindowsCritics gave this single-player Uncharted collection 87 out of 100 across 149 reviews, and the series' strong writing and acting are why.8.7
- Sniper Elite 5 2022Sniper Elite 5 builds its best levels yet around a familiar formulaCritics praised the sprawling maps, tunable rifles and the new invasion mode, while some found the missions repetitive and the story thin.7.7
- Company of Heroes 3 2022Company of Heroes 3 nails the battles but stumbles on its Italian campaign mapRelic's sequel to Company of Heroes 2 keeps the squad fights, adds a tactical pause and finer destruction, and splits critics on its campaign.7.8
- Ready or Not 2021Ready or Not pays you to take suspects alive, and every doorway tests thatA slow, punishing SWAT shooter that critics rated well, built around arrests over kills, with subject matter that drew sharp criticism.8.0
- Vampire Survivors — First Survivaton 2021Vampire Survivors turns steering alone into a loop critics couldn't put downYou only steer. The weapons fire themselves, the screen fills up, and a 30-minute clock decides when the run ends.8.2
- Halo Infinite 2021Halo Infinite opens the ring up, and critics called it the best Halo in yearsHalo Infinite's campaign trades corridors for a semi-open ringworld and gives Master Chief a grappling hook. Its multiplayer is free-to-play.8.2
- Farming Simulator 22 2021Farming Simulator 22 sticks to the series' calm, repetitive farm loopGiants Software's 2021 entry scored 74/100 with critics. It suits patient players and will test anyone who wants surprises.7.4
- Battlefield 2042 2021Battlefield 2042 built 128-player fights on a launch too buggy to hold themA multiplayer-only Battlefield with huge maps and a strong Portal mode, held back at launch by bugs, thin features and a divisive class overhaul.6.2
- Forza Horizon 5 2021Forza Horizon 5 makes its fictional Mexico the main event, and it worksThe biggest Horizon map yet turns a varied, weather-swept Mexico into the reason to play, though critics flagged easy handling and constant pings.9.0
- Jurassic World Evolution 2 2021Jurassic World Evolution 2 makes its dinosaurs fight for their own groundFrontier's park builder gives its animals real needs and rivalries, and critics called it a clear step up from the first game.7.9
- Football Manager 2022 2021Football Manager 2022 fine-tunes a proven squad instead of rebuilding itSports Interactive's 2021 management sim won critics over with small, targeted fixes and a depth that makes coasting at the top harder.8.7
- Age of Empires IV 2021Age of Empires IV rebuilds Age of Empires II for a new decade and rarely straysRelic's 2021 medieval strategy game won over critics with eight distinct civilizations at launch, even as several called it too safe.8.1
- Darkest Dungeon II 2021Darkest Dungeon II makes a party's nerves as dangerous as the roadRed Hook's roguelike sequel earned steady scores in the low 80s by making stress, friendships and grudges matter as much as the monsters.8.0
- Inscryption 2021Inscryption's cabin won critics over, and its later acts split themA horror card game that keeps changing shape. Critics agreed on the eerie first act and argued about everything after it.8.7
- Against the Storm 2021Against the Storm makes you abandon every city, and critics loved it for thatA city builder where the storm wipes out each settlement, with runs of about an hour and a clear goal. Aggregate scores sit at 89 to 91.9.0
- Back 4 Blood 2021Back 4 Blood adds a card deck to Turtle Rock's four-player zombie formulaTurtle Rock's 2021 co-op shooter built a deck system on top of the four-survivor horde fight. Critics liked it but kept tripping on the pacing.7.2
- Far Cry 6 2021Far Cry 6 gives the guerrilla fight louder tools but rarely makes it newHolstered guns, homemade Resolver weapons and an island that toughens as you do sharpen a formula that some critics found worn and hollow.7.5
- FIFA 22 2021FIFA 22 plays its best match on new consoles and its worst in the packsHyperMotion made matches feel heavier and more responsive, critics said, but the Switch version stood still and the card packs drew a damning report.7.8
- New World 2021New World's aim-based combat kept players coming back as critics stayed splitAmazon's colonial-fantasy MMORPG earned a Game Awards nomination and long runs near Steam's top, but its critic scores never got past mixed.7.0
- Death Stranding Director's Cut 2021Death Stranding Director's Cut turns hauling cargo into the whole pointCritics agreed the deliveries are the game. They split on whether that's a strength or a slog, and the answer tells you if it's for you.8.6
- NBA 2K22 2021NBA 2K22 scored well with critics, but only 59% would recommend itCritics gave NBA 2K22 solid marks but held back their endorsements, and its online servers went dark at the end of 2023.7.7
- Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous 2021Wrath of the Righteous wins on story and stumbles on its war campaignCritics praised Owlcat's Pathfinder sequel for its story and technical polish, but they flagged uneven writing and weak military management.8.1
- Humankind 2021Humankind lets you swap cultures every era, and that idea carries the gameAmplitude's first 4X set in human history takes its city building from Endless Legend and adds a culture change in each of six eras.7.8
- Naraka: Bladepoint 2021Swords and grappling hooks make this 60-player battle royale worth a free tryA wuxia battle royale built around melee duels and 29 heroes. Critics respected it more than they loved it, and it costs nothing to start.7.0
- Guilty Gear Strive 2021Guilty Gear Strive rebuilds the series and drops its signature moveArc System Works rebuilt its own fighter, cut the Instant Kill, added Wall Break, and critics called the result a milestone.8.4
- Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade 2021Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade wins on combat and loses time to fillerCritics loved the fighting and the cast of this remake set in Midgar, but split over how much slow filler sits between the big moments.8.7
- Chivalry 2 2021Chivalry 2 makes 64-player sieges sing, but its deathmatch modes fall flatCritics called its siege battles a rare mix of skill and slapstick. Its smaller modes earned far less praise.8.2
- PowerWash Simulator 2021PowerWash Simulator turns one dirty job into 38 calm, satisfying onesFuturLab's first-person cleaning game wins critics with a relaxing loop and co-op, though repetition and slow final stretches drag at times.7.8
- Mass Effect Legendary Edition 2021Legendary Edition rebuilds the first Mass Effect and keeps the trilogy wholeBioWare's remaster gives the 2007 original new combat, driving and loading, folds in the expansions, and won a 96% critic recommendation rate.8.7
- Resident Evil Village 2021Resident Evil Village trades haunted-house dread for a village full of fightsCapcom's 2021 sequel keeps the first-person view of Resident Evil 7 and adds more enemies, more guns and a village to explore.8.4
- Monster Hunter Rise 2021Monster Hunter Rise turns a slow, heavy series vertical with one grappling bugCapcom's 2021 hunter is built around the Wirebug, and critics agreed it made hunts faster, friendlier and more open than before.8.7
- It Takes Two 2021Critics loved It Takes Two's co-op far more than its marriage storyHazelight's two-player-only adventure won Game of the Year at The Game Awards 2021, though some critics found its script uneven.8.9
- Dorfromantik 2021Dorfromantik is a calm tile puzzle critics found lovely, if sometimes shallowHex tiles, quiet villages and a scoring system that rewards precision. Critics agreed on the charm and split on how long it holds up.8.5
- Skul: The Hero Slayer 2021Skul's head-swapping combat won critics over, even where its story didn'tA skeleton roguelite built on swappable skulls. Critics loved how it fights, argued over how it sounds, and mostly shrugged at its story.8.2
- Hitman 3 2021Hitman 3 rewards patient planners with the series' best sandbox levelsIO Interactive's trilogy finale drew the best reviews in the series for its levels, but critics split on its story and disliked its train finale.8.6
- Cyberpunk 2077 2020Cyberpunk 2077 rewards the build you choose, if you skip last-gen consolesCritics loved Night City's story and side quests, split on its combat and driving, and still warn PS4 and Xbox One owners away.7.6
- Football Manager 2021 2020Football Manager 2021 sharpens a proven sim but keeps its tired press roomCritics found the eighteenth Football Manager livelier on the pitch and easier to read, with repetitive interviews as the main complaint.8.7
- Call of Duty: Black Ops Cold War 2020Black Ops Cold War works best for campaign and Zombies fans, not lobby veteransA short, choice-driven 1981 spy campaign and a friendly Zombies mode carry a 2020 Call of Duty whose multiplayer left critics divided.7.7
- Spider-Man: Miles Morales 2020Miles Morales keeps the 2018 formula and adds Harlem and bio-electric powersInsomniac's 2020 spin-off reuses its predecessor's Manhattan and core play, then adds bio-electric powers, a tighter story and Harlem.8.4
- Spider-Man Remastered 2020Insomniac's 2018 Spider-Man returns on PS5 and PC with its swinging intactThe remaster keeps the game critics praised for traversal, combat and story, along with the worn open-world habits they flagged.8.8
- Assassin's Creed Valhalla 2020Valhalla gives Assassin's Creed its best balance yet, at the cost of sheer bulkCritics praised the Viking raids, the story and the mix of systems, while the length, bugs and familiar formula drew the sharpest objections.8.2
- Teardown 2020Teardown is for players who plan for an hour and escape in sixty secondsA voxel demolition heist game whose physics and ray-traced lighting won critics over, even as its campaign pacing drew complaints.8.0
- Solasta: Crown of the Magister 2020Solasta plays 5th edition D&D straight, and the turn-based combat is the payoffCritics praised the tactical fights built on tabletop Dungeons & Dragons rules and found the clichéd story the weakest part.7.5
- Age of Empires III: Definitive Edition 2020A handsome Age of Empires III remaster that critics faulted on pathfindingCritics liked the new look and campaign changes in this 2020 remaster. Their main complaint was how units find their way around the map.7.7
- Baldur's Gate 3 2020Baldur's Gate 3 turns every lock, lie and sword swing into a dice rollLarian's take on fifth edition D&D earned near-universal praise for its freedom and characters, with a buggier third act as the main catch.9.6
- Mafia: Definitive Edition 2020Mafia's remake rebuilds Lost Heaven but keeps the 2002 game's bonesHangar 13's 2020 remake of Mafia won praise for its cast, driving and 1930s city. Critics pushed back on combat they called dated.7.9
- Crusader Kings III 2020Crusader Kings III makes every medieval ruler a character whose flaws matterParadox's dynasty simulator ties strategy to personality, and critics called the PC version one of the best strategy games of its year.8.9
- Spiritfarer 2020Spiritfarer turns saying goodbye into a daily routine of cooking and buildingA cozy management game about ferrying the dead, praised for its writing and faulted for chores that repeat once the story slows down.8.5
- Fall Guys 2020Fall Guys turns the battle royale into a wobbly 32-player obstacle courseMediatonic's free-to-play party game wins on chaos and charm, but a thin update pipeline leaves its future looking uncertain.7.9
- Grounded 2020Obsidian traded dialogue trees for a backyard full of spiders, and it workedGrounded shrinks four kids to ant size and makes the lawn the enemy. It was a big turn for a role-playing studio, and critics and players went along with it.7.9
- Command & Conquer Remastered Collection 2020Tiberian Dawn and Red Alert rebuilt with care, and critics barely complainedPetroglyph's remaster of the first two Command & Conquer games packs about 100 missions and earned a 92% critic recommendation rate.8.3
- Monster Train 2020Monster Train turns the deckbuilder into a four-floor defense of a burning pyreShiny Shoe's roguelike deckbuilder earned a 9/10 from IGN and two award nominations, and its appeal is depth that keeps paying out over many runs.8.5
- Mafia II: Definitive Edition 2020Mafia II plays like a mob film you drive through, for better and worseCritics praised its gangster drama and 1940s city, but the Definitive Edition's scores show a story that outshines what you actually do in it.6.6
- Deep Rock Galactic 2020Deep Rock Galactic is best with three friends and a stable connectionCritics loved how its four dwarf classes fit together. The one sour note was online play that could drop teammates mid-mission.8.4
- SnowRunner 2020SnowRunner turns a single delivery over rough ground into the whole gameSaber Interactive's off-road simulator asks you to haul cargo through disaster zones, and critics found the slow grind worth it.8.0
- Resident Evil 3 2020Resident Evil 3 trades the slow dread of exploration for a short, loud chaseCapcom's 2020 remake of Resident Evil 3: Nemesis looks superb and moves fast, but critics found it short and its famous stalker underused.7.9
- Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord 2020Bannerlord's battles deliver, but its kingdoms exist mainly to be burnedCritics agree the fighting is the reason to play Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord. The strategy layer meant to give that fighting a purpose is thinner.7.9
- Doom Eternal 2020Doom Eternal turns every demon into a pickup for health, ammo or armorid Software's 2020 shooter makes resource juggling the core of its combat, and critics called the result one of the most intense shooters around.8.7
- Nioh 2 2020Nioh 2 keeps the punishing core and adds yōkai powers that change every fightTeam Ninja's prequel builds on the 2017 original with Soul Cores, Burst Counters and a custom hero, and critics called it a stronger game.8.4
- Ori and the Will of the Wisps 2020Ori and the Will of the Wisps proves its maker can do it twiceMoon Studios' sequel sharpens the platforming, adds real combat and a hub to build up, and critics rated it above the 2015 original.8.9
- Zombie Army 4: Dead War 2020Zombie Army 4 is a sharp co-op shooter that doesn't pretend to be smartCritics loved Rebellion's zombie shooter with friends and warned against expecting depth, and most aggregates sit at 75/100.7.4
- Romance of the Three Kingdoms XIV 2020Romance of the Three Kingdoms XIV lets you rule as anyone, but battles dragKoei's 14th Three Kingdoms game hands you all of China, but critics found its battles slow and its English localization rough.6.4
- MechWarrior 5: Mercenaries 2019Players warmed to the first solo MechWarrior since 2002 more than criticsCritics scored Piranha Games' mech simulation between 72 and 74 out of 100, while Steam players rated it 83% positive and bought two million copies.7.3
- Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order 2019Fallen Order makes every lightsaber parry count across five tangled planetsCritics praised its demanding saber combat and maze-like planets, and flagged slow backtracking and shaky technical performance.8.2
- Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition 2019Age of Empires II's 1999 village-to-castle loop holds up in 4KA remaster of a medieval strategy classic that critics called polished and generous, with complaints about pathfinding and how strong new civilizations launch.8.6
- Need for Speed Heat 2019Need for Speed Heat trades safe daytime cash for risky night repCritics agreed it put the series back on track. They split on whether a mix of familiar ideas was enough to carry it.7.2
- Planet Zoo 2019Planet Zoo rewards patient zoo planners and tests everyone elseCritics loved its depth and its animals, then warned that the same depth can bury players who only came to see giraffes.8.1
- Persona 5 Royal 2019Persona 5 Royal gives the sixth Persona the ending it was missingAtlus's enhanced Persona 5 adds a third semester, new characters and a livelier Mementos, and critics rated it above the original.9.5
- Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2019Modern Warfare's reboot traded arcade speed for tension, and mostly wonInfinity Ward's 2019 restart of its Modern Warfare line slowed Call of Duty down, and critics rated it among the series' best campaigns.7.9
- Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Breakpoint 2019Breakpoint bolts survival and loot onto Wildlands and commits to neitherUbisoft Paris's 2019 sequel added fatigue, injuries and gear levels to Ghost Recon, and critics found most of it easy to ignore.5.5
- Code Vein 2019Code Vein borrows from Dark Souls, adds anime weirdness, and splits criticsBandai Namco's 2019 vampire action RPG had ideas critics admired and long stretches between them that some found tiresome.7.5
- Noita 2019Noita makes every pixel a physics problem and builds a roguelike on topNolla Games kept the classic dungeon descent and changed what the dungeon is made of. Critics mostly approved, and awards juries noticed early.8.0
- Borderlands 3 2019Borderlands 3 sharpens the shooting and leaves the jokes up for debateCritics agreed the guns, skills and movement improved. They split on the humor and the story, and that split decides who should play it.7.9
- Blasphemous 2019Blasphemous makes every death cost you something, and critics mostly bought itThe Game Kitchen's 2019 Metroidvania turns guilt into a rule of play. Critics loved its look, combat and bosses but not its backtracking.8.0
- Green Hell 2019Green Hell makes the Amazon an opponent that tracks your diet, sleep and woundsCreepy Jar's survival game measures the player's body, not just their stockpile, and critics rated it well across six platforms.7.9
- Control 2019Control makes a shifting government building the star of a strong shooterRemedy's 2019 action game earned Game of the Year awards for the Oldest House, a setting that carries its combat and outlasts its thin lead.8.2
- Hunt: Showdown 1896 2019A slow, tense bounty hunt for players who'd rather stalk than sprintA tense, slow extraction shooter where every gunshot and every crow gives you away. Critics loved the dread but noted it had few maps.7.8
- Remnant: From the Ashes 2019Guns meet Dark Souls bosses in a co-op shooter that mostly worksA punishing third-person shooter with random worlds and three-player co-op. Critics loved the boss fights and co-op but not the gear or the story.7.7
- Gloomhaven 2019Gloomhaven turns every attack into a card you may never get backA faithful digital take on the tabletop dungeon crawler, where a shrinking hand of cards is both your toolkit and your clock.7.8
- Hell Let Loose 2019Hell Let Loose lives or dies on whether your 50-player team talksA 100-player World War II shooter where critics found the best moments in coordinated squads and the weakest in its muted sound.7.6
- Assetto Corsa Competizione 2019Assetto Corsa Competizione is a deep GT3 sim that ran rough on older consolesCritics praised its handling, weather and AI. They faulted the PS4 and Xbox One versions and a narrower car list than the original.7.2
- Outer Wilds 2019Outer Wilds lets you keep only what you learn, and that turns out to be enoughA 22-minute time loop wipes everything but your ship's log, and critics found that one rule could carry a whole solar system of mysteries.8.6
- Last Epoch 2019Last Epoch turned a $250,000 Kickstarter into a two-million-copy loot gameEleventh Hour Games' time-travel hack and slash scored between 77 and 80 with critics on every version they covered, and players turned up in large numbers.7.9
- Mordhau 2019Mordhau's sword fights reward patience, and its learning curve punishes itA 64-player medieval brawler that critics loved for its deep melee, and faulted for teaching it badly and for a community left largely unpoliced.8.2
- Imperator: Rome 2019A deep Roman strategy game that rewards patience and loses everyone elseCritics found a dense, well-built Roman strategy game. They split on whether its depth welcomes players or walls them out.7.9
- Mortal Kombat 11 2019Mortal Kombat 11 fights brilliantly, then makes you grind for the extrasCritics loved the slower, deeper fighting and the story mode, but the online-only progression and random Krypt rewards drew the sharpest complaints.8.4
- World War Z 2019World War Z's 1,000-zombie hordes carry a shooter critics rated fineSaber Interactive's four-player zombie shooter drew critic scores from 67/100 to 8.25/10, and it plays best with a full squad on voice chat.7.0
- Anno 1800 2019Anno 1800 takes Anno back to the Industrial Revolution, and critics approvedUbisoft Blue Byte's seventh Anno game trades the far future for the 19th century and drew steady, broad praise across PC and consoles.8.3
- Risk of Rain 2 2019Risk of Rain 2 makes a ticking clock the enemy you never beatHopoo Games' 3D roguelite gets harder every minute you survive, and critics rated it 86/100 across every platform it reached.8.6
- Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice 2019Sekiro trades health bars for posture and demands near-perfect timingCritics called FromSoftware's samurai game its sharpest combat yet. A vocal minority found its difficulty too punishing to enjoy.9.0
- Satisfactory 2019Satisfactory left critics with almost nothing to argue aboutCritics scored it 90 or above on every platform, so the real question is whether you want an automation game you build and walk through in first person.9.1
- Tom Clancy's The Division 2 2019The Division 2 pairs tight gunfights with a Washington, D.C. worth exploringCritics praised the shooting, the city and an endgame that keeps paying off, and they nearly all panned the story.8.4
- Devil May Cry 5 2019Devil May Cry 5 grades every combo and gives three fighters new ways to scoreCapcom's 2019 demon brawler rewards variety in every fight. Critics loved the combat and were cooler on the story.8.7
- Dirt Rally 2.0 2019Dirt Rally 2.0 makes the road itself the opponent, and keeps the punishmentCodemasters' follow-up to Dirt Rally adds weather that changes grip and stages that break up under traffic. It still has no rewind button.8.2
- Metro Exodus 2019Metro Exodus takes Artyom out of the tunnels and rewards players who planA slow, scavenging shooter about planning ahead. Critics loved its open levels and its train crew, and some found the shooting itself too ordinary.8.2
- Apex Legends 2019Apex Legends drops the Titans and keeps the movement that made Titanfall funRespawn turned its Titanfall universe into a free battle royale, and critics singled out the gunplay and a ping system the genre still borrows from.8.3
- Subnautica: Below Zero 2019Below Zero keeps Subnautica's ocean and slips when it walks onto the iceUnknown Worlds' spin-off adds a voiced lead, cold-weather survival and far more land. Critics liked nearly all of it except the land.8.1
- Resident Evil 2 2019Critics called this rebuilt 1998 classic the gold standard for remakesCapcom's 2019 Resident Evil 2 remake drew near-universal praise for its scares and modern controls, and critics struggled to name a real flaw.9.2
- My Time At Portia 2019Portia is a slow crafting life that charms and drags in turnCritics liked the town, the crafting and the calm, but kept running into the waiting, the long load times and the dull mining.7.3
- Tropico 6 2019Tropico 6 spreads El Presidente across an archipelago and adds bridgesThe sixth Tropico keeps Tropico 5's four eras, then breaks the island into a chain and simulates every citizen. Critics mostly liked the result.7.7
- Slay the Spire 2019Slay the Spire rewards players who like turning bad cards downA turn-based card battler built around reading enemy intent and trimming your deck, with critics near-unanimous in its favor.9.0
- Outward 2019Outward makes you a commoner, and critics couldn't agree that's funA survival-heavy open world role-playing game with no manual saves, middling scores and a recommend rate that tells a sharper story.6.5
- Football Manager 2020 2019Football Manager 2020 rewards patience with its new Development CentreCritics praised its long-term club building and easier entry for newcomers, and complained about press conferences and striker AI.8.6
- Kingdom Two Crowns 2018Kingdom Two Crowns makes coin-counting tense, and co-op argues with thatA slow, pixel-art strategy game where a defenseless monarch spends gold to survive the night, with critics split on its new two-player mode.7.8
- Hades 2018Hades makes every failed escape count, and critics barely found a flawSupergiant's Underworld roguelike earned near-universal praise. The one real complaint, about its combat, shows who will love it.9.4
- Farming Simulator 19 2018Farming Simulator 19 trades thrills for a calm, slow-growing farm businessA patient farm sim for players who like routine work and real machinery, and a hard sell for anyone who needs pressure or surprises.7.0
- Fallout 76 2018Fallout 76 took Bethesda's wasteland online and left its people behindBethesda's online prequel kept the Fallout look and systems, but critics called the launch buggy and empty. Few reviews say it has recovered since.4.9
- Spyro Reignited Trilogy 2018Spyro Reignited Trilogy rebuilds three classic platformers, flaws includedToys for Bob remade the first three Spyro games for modern consoles, keeping the old levels and the old flaws.8.3
- Football Manager 2019 2018Football Manager 2019 rebuilt training and added the Bundesliga licenceCritics rated Sports Interactive's 2018 manager sim the series' best yet, but found it hard to learn and the Nintendo Switch version weaker.8.7
- Assassin's Creed Odyssey 2018Assassin's Creed Odyssey trades the hidden blade for a war in ancient GreeceCritics scored Ubisoft Quebec's 2018 open-world role-playing game from 82/100 to 87/100, but its level gates and light stealth won't suit every fan.8.4
- Forza Horizon 4 2018Forza Horizon 4 lets the seasons steal the show from a too-tidy BritainCritics loved how weekly weather reshapes every race, and the main complaint was a postcard version of Britain with the rough edges removed.9.0
- Pathfinder: Kingmaker 2018Kingmaker rewards patient tabletop fans with a kingdom worth rulingA deep, tabletop-style RPG with a kingdom to run, held back by uneven difficulty and a PS4 version that still crashes.7.1
- Insurgency: Sandstorm 2018Sandstorm makes every shot lethal so every teammate mattersA tactical shooter where a few bullets kill, the HUD tells you almost nothing, and the dead wait for their team to win them back.7.9
- Shadow of the Tomb Raider 2018Shadow of the Tomb Raider's tombs are the series' best; its story is notCritics praised the puzzles, climbing and stealth in Lara Croft's 2018 trilogy finale, but many found the story and its hero hard to follow or like.7.7
- Two Point Hospital 2018Two Point Hospital makes curing light bulb heads a tidy management puzzleA spiritual successor to Theme Hospital that critics loved for its jokes and clear interface, though its later hospitals can feel alike.8.0
- Graveyard Keeper 2018Graveyard Keeper turns the cozy farm-sim loop into a job digging gravesA medieval-fantasy management sim built on the farming-game template, with a cemetery where the crops would be. Critics came away mixed.7.0
- The Crew 2 2018The Crew 2 bets on switching from car to plane to boat in an instantUbisoft Ivory Tower's 2018 sequel shrinks the contiguous US into one open map for racing in any vehicle. Critics scored it squarely in the middle.6.4
- Among Us 2018Among Us is sharpest as an Impostor and only as good as your groupA simple game about tasks and lies earned strong praise on PC, but critics found the Crewmate role tiring and some versions weaker than others.7.9
- Detroit: Become Human 2018Quantic Dream's android drama makes choices count but fumbles its themesCritics praised how deeply its three android stories branch and faulted the heavy-handed writing that carries them.8.2
- Dark Souls: Remastered 2018The 2011 game that teaches by killing you returns, cleaner but unchangedQLOC's remaster keeps Dark Souls' punishing learn-by-dying design intact, and critics found little to fault beyond the price and the cheaters.8.4
- State of Decay 2 2018State of Decay 2 keeps its predecessor's shape and builds it around co-opUndead Labs' 2018 sequel adds friends and more base options to its zombie survival. Critics liked the fights but found shallow systems and plenty of bugs.6.8
- Conan Exiles 2018Conan Exiles sold like a hit while critics kept calling it averageFuncom's survival sandbox has thralls, god-summoning raids and a map that kept growing, but critic scores settled at 68/100 on every platform.7.0
- Frostpunk 2018Frostpunk makes every law you pass in a frozen city feel like a moral costA city-builder where heat, hope and hard laws decide survival, praised for its moral weight and faulted for a campaign that plays out the same way twice.8.5
- BattleTech 2018BattleTech split critics on how good it is, never on whether it's goodHarebrained Schemes' turn-based mech tactics game scored from 7/10 to 81/100. That spread says more about its players than its quality.7.9
- God of War 2018God of War trades long combos for a thrown axe and a son to protectSanta Monica Studio rebuilt Kratos around a recallable axe, a camera that never cuts away, and a story critics ranked among the PS4's best.9.4
- Total War: Three Kingdoms 2018Three Kingdoms wins on its generals' grudges more than on its battlefieldsCritics praised its character-driven campaign and Romance mode, while the real-time battles drew the series' familiar complaints.8.4
- Far Cry 5 2018Far Cry 5 builds a great Montana sandbox around a story critics shrugged atHope County opens up early and rewards wandering, but critics found the cult story thin and its endings an undercut to everything before them.8.2
- Sea of Thieves 2018Sea of Thieves shines with a crew of friends and sags when you sail aloneRare's shared-world pirate game won critics over as a social sandbox, but its launch quests were called thin and repetitive.6.8
- Warhammer: Vermintide 2 2018Vermintide 2's melee won critics over, but its loot system split themA brutal four-player war on rat-men and Chaos that critics loved swinging through, and argued about once the loot screen appeared.8.4
- Age of Empires: Definitive Edition 2018The Age of Empires remake sells an empire and plays like a warThe 1997 classic promised a civilization grown across four ages; critics found a combat game first. The 2018 remake keeps that bargain.6.9
- Rust 2018Rust turns every resource run into a gamble against other playersFacepunch Studios' survival sandbox has no story and no win condition. Critics found its fights thrilling and its grind punishing for anyone who can't commit.7.1
- Monster Hunter: World 2018Capcom's monster hunt opens up to newcomers but keeps the steep climbCapcom's 2018 hunting game earned near-universal acclaim. Critics mostly disagreed over how much a first-time hunter has to learn before it clicks.9.0
- Dragon Ball FighterZ 2018Arc System Works turned Dragon Ball into a serious three-on-three fighterThe team behind Guilty Gear Xrd built a tag fighter that critics called the best Dragon Ball game and one of the best fighting games in years.8.6
- Overcooked 2 2018Overcooked 2 makes four cooks in one kitchen a fun, deliberate kind of chaosCritics called it a sharper, fairer version of the original's co-op cooking panic, not a new formula, and it works best when friends play together.8.2
- Lost Ark 2018Lost Ark's combat won critics over, but its questing grind split themCritics praised the fighting in Smilegate's MMO action RPG. Whether the chores and thin story around it are worth your hours is where they parted ways.8.2
- Beat Saber 2018Beat Saber turns one sword swing into a reason to own a VR headsetCritics called it a game that feels native to virtual reality: slice blocks to the beat with two glowing sabers, and little else gets in the way.8.6
- They Are Billions 2017They Are Billions rewards careful planners, but critics never fully lined upA steampunk zombie siege that critics rated solidly, if not uniformly, and that punishes one gap in a wall harder than most strategy games do.7.3
- Assassin's Creed Origins 2017Assassin's Creed Origins makes Ancient Egypt worth the level grindA huge, detailed Egypt and deeper combat won critics over, though level gates and filler side content slow the revenge story that drives it.8.6
- Middle-earth: Shadow of War 2017Shadow of War's orc army outshines its story and its sprawlCritics loved the nemesis system's orcs, tired of a bloated map and a lore-bending plot, and widely panned the war chest loot boxes.8.1
- Cuphead 2017Cuphead's boss fights won critics over until the last ones pushed too hardCritics loved Cuphead's 1930s cartoon look and its boss fights, then split over whether the final stretch gets too hard.8.9
- Total War: Warhammer II 2017Warhammer II added four races and a map that joins both gamesCreative Assembly's 2017 sequel kept the turn-and-battle formula, added four new races and a story campaign, and gave owners of both games a huge sandbox.8.4
- Destiny 2 2017Destiny 2's shooting won critics over while its side activities split themCritics agreed the gunplay is superb and split on the filler between missions, which tells you whether the grind will hook you.8.4
- Ark: Survival Evolved 2017Ark tames dinosaurs brilliantly, then buries the fun under hours of grindingStudio Wildcard's survival sandbox kept growing for years. Critics loved its creatures and its world but kept running into the grind.6.3
- The Long Dark 2017The Long Dark turns cold and hunger into the whole fightA first-person survival game in the Canadian wilderness that critics praised for its mood and faulted for how fast it eats through supplies.7.8
- Slime Rancher 2017Slime Rancher turns vacuuming up cheerful slimes into a calm, sticky routineA first-person ranching sim about feeding slimes, selling plorts and keeping the Tarr away. Critics found it relaxing and addictive but repetitive.7.6
- Dead Cells 2017Dead Cells made dying the core loop and started a series doing itMotion Twin's roguevania mixed random level layouts with Metroidvania routes. Critics loved the combat and mostly shrugged at the story.8.7
- Rain World 2017Rain World builds a living food chain, then makes you fight its controlsCritics praised the art and the creatures' independent lives, and many found the controls, checkpoints and karma gates punishing past the point of fun.7.1
- PUBG: Battlegrounds 2017The Battlegrounds mod that grew into the model every battle royale followsPUBG: Battlegrounds kept the slow, deliberate gunfights of military shooters and wrapped them in 30-minute rounds that anyone could start in seconds.8.0
- Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Wildlands 2017Ghost Recon Wildlands is built for four friends and a loose planA huge Bolivia, a cartel to take apart and co-op that critics loved, held back by repetitive missions and stiff aiming.7.2
- For the King 2017For the King turns tabletop dice rolls into a punishing co-op roguelikeIronOak Games' first For the King mixes a hex map, percentage rolls and permadeath. Critics found it rewarding and sometimes cruel.7.5
- Northgard 2017Northgard turns every patch of land and every winter into a hard choiceShiro Games' Viking strategy game won critics over with its tight building limits and harsh seasons, even though its story fell flat.7.8
- Sniper Elite 4 2017Sniper Elite 4 gives patient snipers huge maps but forgets about its storyCritics praised the long-range shooting and open levels in Rebellion's 2017 shooter. The plot, sidearms and enemy AI drew steady complaints.7.9
- For Honor 2017For Honor turns medieval melee into a guessing game of guard and strikeUbisoft Montreal's standalone sword fighter swapped a shooter's guns for blades but kept its structure, and critics rewarded the risk with a 78.7.8
- Resident Evil 7: Biohazard 2017Resident Evil 7 finds its fear in one Louisiana house, then loses it to bossesCritics called the Baker house one of the creepiest settings in Resident Evil. The boss fights and the ending got most of the complaints.8.6
- Star Wars Battlefront II 2017Star Wars Battlefront II fixed its multiplayer but never its thin campaignDICE's 2017 shooter launched with a loot crate fight and a safe campaign, then earned a far kinder second look for its multiplayer.6.6
- Astroneer 2016Astroneer swaps hunger and thirst for an oxygen leash, and it mostly worksA calm, good-looking sandbox about digging, crafting and stretching tethers across alien planets, held back by thin worlds and rough edges.7.5
- Killing Floor 2 2016Killing Floor 2 sharpens the six-player horde fight but keeps its thin storyTripwire's 2016 sequel adds perks, zed time and harder tiers to the wave shooter. Critics still found too few maps and too much repetition.7.5
- Planet Coaster 2016Planet Coaster hands you the building tools and lets the park be the gameFrontier's 2016 theme park sim earned its praise for its creative tools. Its career mode, camera and big-park performance drew the complaints.8.4
- Watch Dogs 2 2016Watch Dogs 2 is at its best when the hacker leaves the gun at homeCritics praised a sharper, funnier sequel built around a phone that hacks a whole city, then asked why its peaceful hero carries home-made guns.8.1
- Football Manager 2017 2016Football Manager 2017 sharpens player growth but changes little from last yearCritics praised its transfers and player development, while The Guardian found the fourteenth Football Manager too close to the editions before it.7.9
- Titanfall 2 2016Titanfall 2 turns every wall into a road, and critics loved the rideRespawn's 2016 shooter builds everything around fast pilot movement and a giant robot partner, and GamesRadar called it the year's surprise.8.8
- Civilization VI 2016Civilization VI spreads each city across the map, and critics backed the changeFiraxis kept Civilization V's hex grid and moved city buildings onto their own tiles. Reviewers called it the deepest launch the series had seen.8.7
- Mafia III 2016Mafia III pairs a standout revenge story with missions that repeatCritics loved Lincoln Clay and 1968 New Bordeaux, but most found the open-world busywork and launch bugs hard to forgive.6.5
- Endless Space 2 2016Endless Space 2 rewards players who like running every system and lawAmplitude Studios' turn-based space 4X gives you factions that play differently, a deep empire layer and steady 81 to 82 critic averages.8.1
- Human: Fall Flat 2016A clumsy body is the whole puzzle, and the joke lands best with friendsA physics puzzler about steering a wobbly figure named Bob, which critics found more fun to laugh at than to master alone.7.3
- Starbound 2016Starbound kept its procedural sandbox and spent years adding a storyChucklefish's 2D space sandbox left early access in 2016, then added a story, mechs and an ending. Critics liked it from the start.8.5
- Dead by Daylight 2016Dead by Daylight grew from a shaky 2016 launch into the standard for 1v4 horrorBehaviour Interactive's game pits one Killer against four Survivors, and critics say years of fixes made the hunt sharp and deep.7.2
- Hearts of Iron IV 2016Hearts of Iron IV kept the war and rebuilt the economy that feeds itParadox's fourth Hearts of Iron lets you run any nation through World War II, and critics praised its depth while warning about the climb to learn it.8.0
- Doom 2016Doom pays out health and ammo for charging straight at demonsThe 2016 reboot builds its campaign on aggression. Critics loved the result, though its multiplayer and map editor drew more mixed praise.8.6
- Stellaris 2016Stellaris is strongest when your empire is young and when the crisis comesCritics praised the species builder, the RPG-like opening and the end-game crises, but found the middle stretch thin on diplomacy and rival ambition.8.0
- Dark Souls III 2016Dark Souls III makes every swing cost stamina and every death cost soulsFromSoftware's last Dark Souls is faster than the games before it, with bosses critics loved and a world some found more linear than the earlier ones.8.9
- Tom Clancy's The Division 2016Massive's first Snowdrop game built a looter shooter around a deadly Dark ZoneThe Division brought online role-playing structure to a cover shooter in a frozen Manhattan. Critics liked the guns and the Dark Zone more than the city.7.9
- Ultimate Chicken Horse 2016Ultimate Chicken Horse makes you survive the traps you build for your friendsA party platformer where each player adds an obstacle, then races the others to a flag. Critics liked it but wanted more help for new builders.7.9
- Stardew Valley 2016Stardew Valley rewards patient farmers once its slow early hours passA farm sim built on small daily goals, praised for its townsfolk and music, and faulted for a thin tutorial and a lot of walking.9.0
- Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare 2 2016Garden Warfare 2 puts serious shooter bones under a silly cartoon warPopCap's 2016 sequel adds solo campaigns, 10 new classes and a full zombie side, and critics found the goofy shooter got sturdier.8.0
- XCOM 2 2016XCOM 2 splits critics over its turn timers, and that tells you who it's forFiraxis's resistance-era sequel won broad praise, but critics disagreed sharply about how hard its timed missions push and what its launch bugs cost it.8.6
- Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm 4 2016Naruto's last Storm game wins on spectacle and splits critics on depthUltimate Ninja Storm 4 has 106 fighters and a huge war story. Critics agreed on the spectacle and disagreed on whether the fighting goes deep.7.6
- American Truck Simulator 2016American Truck Simulator turns long hauls into a calm, patient businessSCS Software's open-road trucking sim rewards careful driving and slow growth. Critics liked it, with a few reservations about realism and its launch state.7.8
- Golf With Your Friends 2016Golf With Your Friends lives or dies on who is holding the other clubsCritics split hard on this 12-player minigolf game. One saw colorful fun, another a barebones, glitchy shell. The group you play with decides it.6.5
- Dragon Ball Xenoverse 2 2016Dragon Ball Xenoverse 2 builds a much bigger city around the same fightsDimps's 2016 sequel adds a hub seven times larger and transformations for every race, but critics found the combat barely changed.7.4
- Darkest Dungeon 2016Darkest Dungeon turns party stress into a second health bar you can't ignoreA punishing turn-based dungeon crawler where fear can break a hero before a monster does, built for patient tacticians.8.4
- Enter the Gungeon 2016Enter the Gungeon turns one gun joke into a punishing, inventive shooterA bullet hell roguelike where the enemies are bullets, the money is casings and the prize is a gun. Critics say the joke holds up under heavy fire.8.3
- Just Cause 3 2015Just Cause 3 turns a whole island into a toy box and loses its plotCritics loved the freedom and the destruction on Medici, but the story and technical problems kept Just Cause 3 in mixed-review territory.7.4
- Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Siege 2015Rainbow Six Siege rewards planning and punishes teams that don't talkCritics praised its tense no-respawn rounds and gadget-heavy operators, then marked it down for thin content, shaky hit detection and slow unlocks.7.9
- Rise of the Tomb Raider 2015Rise of the Tomb Raider saves its best work for the optional tombsA confident sequel with flexible fights, deep challenge tombs and striking scenery in Siberia, weighed down by collecting and a familiar plot.8.5
- Fallout 4 2015Fallout 4 turns every scrap of Boston junk into something worth carrying homeBethesda's 2015 open-world role-playing game pairs sharper gunplay with a settlement builder, and critics forgave most of its old rough edges.8.5
- Call of Duty: Black Ops III 2015Black Ops III wins on sheer volume while critics argue it barely moves forwardTreyarch's 2015 shooter offers four-player co-op, Zombies and a wall-running multiplayer mode. Critics agreed it was big but split on whether it was new.7.4
- Prison Architect 2015Three years in paid alpha made Prison Architect a deep, grim builderIntroversion's prison sim has you build cells, set schedules and cut reoffending. Critics found few builders as deep, once you get past the slow start.8.2
- Undertale 2015Undertale turns the old RPG fight into a choice about mercyToby Fox's 2015 role-playing game keeps an old-school frame, lets you spare every monster and remembers when you don't.9.3
- Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain 2015Metal Gear Solid V's tactical sandbox is the star, not its divisive storyA 2015 stealth game that critics called a tactical toybox, carried by its systems and held back by a story that split reviewers.9.0
- Mad Max 2015Mad Max puts its best ideas in the car and repeats the restAvalanche built a wasteland around one upgradable car. Critics loved the driving and tired of a map full of familiar chores.7.1
- Rocket League 2015Rocket League's floaty ball splits critics, but its team play won them overPsyonix's rocket-car soccer earned 87/100 from critics, who loved the multiplayer and argued for years about how slowly the ball moves.8.7
- Batman: Arkham Knight 2015Arkham Knight gives Batman a tank, and critics mostly forgave him for itRocksteady's fourth Arkham game opens up all of Gotham and adds the Batmobile. The car split critics more than anything else in it.8.7
- The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt 2015The Witcher 3 is a book of dark fantasy short stories with a sword attachedCritics loved the side quests and the world more than the main plot or the combat, and that gap is the best guide to this game.9.4
- Kerbal Space Program 2015Kerbal Space Program turns crashed rockets into the lesson planCritics praised how it makes failure fun, and whether you agree depends on how many rockets you'll lose before your first orbit.8.5
- Mortal Kombat X 2015Mortal Kombat X fights brilliantly but stumbles online and on PCCritics called its fighting the best in the series. Its online play, paid extras and Windows version drew the sharpest complaints.8.6
- Tekken 7 2015Tekken 7 rewards players who do the learning its tutorials skipComeback mechanics and a long competitive life carry this one-on-one 3D fighter past thin solo modes and weak teaching.8.2
- Yakuza 0 2015Yakuza 0 refines the series formula and pays you in cash for every punchA 1988 prequel with two leads, three switchable fighting styles each, and a cabaret club that critics called the best part of the game.8.7
- Cities: Skylines 2015Critics crowned it over SimCity, but it's calm and light on guidanceCritics called it the best city builder in a decade. The common complaint was that its cities run with few surprises and teach new players very little.8.4
- Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number 2015Hotline Miami 2 trades tight rooms for sprawling levels and a split verdictDennaton's 2015 sequel keeps the one-hit kills and a soundtrack critics loved, but its bigger levels and tangled story divided reviewers.7.3
- Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2015Warhorse's first Kingdom Come swaps magic for hunger, armor and hard savesThe series opener built its whole design on period realism, and critics found that same realism to be both its best idea and its biggest problem.7.7
- Total War: Attila 2015Attila turns Rome II's map into a fight to keep a dying empire aliveCreative Assembly's 2015 strategy game sets the series at the fall of Rome, and critics found its battles sharper than its politics and diplomacy.7.9
- Dying Light 2015Dying Light's rooftop running and terrifying nights outshine its busyworkTechland's 2015 zombie game pairs strong first-person parkour and a frightening night cycle with crafting chores and a forgettable story.7.6
- Battle Brothers 2015Battle Brothers is brutal to learn and hard to put downCritics split on whether a punishing mercenary tactics game is worth its weak tutorial and clumsy interface.7.6
- Elite Dangerous 2014Elite Dangerous builds the whole Milky Way and keeps its quiet stretchesCritics called its galaxy among the most convincing ever made, and also, at times, one of the most boring places to spend an evening.7.9
- Subnautica 2014Subnautica is underwater Minecraft with a reason to keep swimming deeperCritics praised the pull of exploring an alien ocean. From early on, the main complaint was crafting recipes that don't explain themselves.8.5
- Dragon Age: Inquisition 2014Inquisition is best when you're running the army, not following the plotBioWare's 2014 role-playing game makes the Inquisitor run an organization. Critics loved that idea, the companions and the combat, and found the plot thin.8.6
- Far Cry 4 2014Far Cry 4 moves Far Cry 3's formula to Kyrat, and critics mostly approvedUbisoft's 2014 shooter packs its mountain kingdom with outposts, elephants and grappling hooks, but critics said the story and the ambition fell short.8.5
- This War of Mine 2014A war game that trades the soldier's rifle for a civilian's empty pantry11 Bit Studios built a war game about the people hiding from the war, and critics found it grim, demanding and hard to put down.8.4
- Assassin's Creed Unity 2014Unity rebuilt Assassin's Creed around one huge Paris and launched brokenThe eighth main Assassin's Creed overhauled combat, stealth and climbing. Critics liked the city and the new ideas but not the bugs at launch.7.1
- Halo: The Master Chief Collection 2014Six Halo campaigns in one package, with a launch one critic called brokenCritics praised the content and remastered graphics in Halo: The Master Chief Collection but split hard over how badly it shipped online.8.8
- Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel 2014Low gravity and ice guns freshen Borderlands, but missions rarely use themThe moon-set spin-off adds floaty jumps, oxygen jetpacks and freeze weapons to the Borderlands 2 formula, then builds missions that mostly ignore them.7.3
- Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor 2014Shadow of Mordor's orcs remember every fight, and that memory carries the gameA Tolkien revenge story built around enemies who hold grudges, with critics praising the system and the combat and doubting the plot.8.3
- The Sims 4 2014The Sims 4 made its Sims deeper and the world around them thinnerCritics loved the emotional, multitasking Sims and the build tools, then called the base game skeletal. Both camps had a point.7.0
- Gang Beasts 2014Gang Beasts is a ragdoll brawler that lives or dies on the people beside youEarly access critics loved its floppy chaos, but the full release got mixed reviews, and that split shows who it still suits.6.3
- Watch Dogs 2014Watch Dogs makes Chicago hackable, but its hacker never comes aliveUbisoft Montreal's 2014 open-world thriller gave critics sharp gunplay and a dense city, then lost most of them with its revenge story.7.7
- Wolfenstein: The New Order 2014The New Order sets a stealth-or-shoot fight in a 1960s the Nazis wonMachineGames brought Wolfenstein back with flexible stealth, heavy gunfights and a story critics argued over, but mostly loved.8.2
- The Elder Scrolls Online 2014Elder Scrolls Online gives Tamriel fans a shared world, but never offlineA big, still-growing Elder Scrolls MMORPG that won critics over after a rough launch. It works best for players who want company in Tamriel.7.3
- Smite 2014Smite drops the MOBA camera behind a god's shoulder, and critics liked the viewHi-Rez Studios' free-to-play battle arena earned strong reviews for its third-person fights and fair pricing, with doubts about ranked play and console polish.8.3
- Black Desert 2014Black Desert trades tab-targeting for aimed combat and a world run by weatherPearl Abyss's sandbox MMORPG drew a warm beta reception and a mixed full release. The split says a lot about who should play it.7.2
- The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth 2014Critics never scored Rebirth below 87, and permadeath is the catchA roguelike shooter that critics rated between 87 and 92, built on random dungeons, stacking items and runs that end for good when you die.8.9
- Final Fantasy X/X-2 HD Remaster 2013Two PS2 classics look far better here, though the fixed camera shows its ageSquare Enix's remaster bundles Final Fantasy X and X-2 with their international extras. Critics loved the core games and split on the new bits.8.6
- 7 Days to Die 20137 Days to Die builds everything around one weekly zombie siegeA voxel survival game where every seventh night brings a horde to your door, and critics scored the result 42/100 and 39/100.4.1
- Assetto Corsa 2013Assetto Corsa put tyre physics first and let modders fill the garageKunos Simulazioni's first Assetto Corsa won PC critics over with its handling, but the console versions drew much cooler reviews.6.6
- Battlefield 4 2013Battlefield 4 is a squad sandbox that critics loved once its servers held upDICE built a large multiplayer playground where teams pick how to win. Critics praised the idea, shrugged at the campaign and hit a buggy launch.8.0
- Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag 2013Black Flag's best hours happen at sea, far from its story missionsA pirate Assassin's Creed whose naval fights and open Caribbean won critics over, even when its main missions and on-foot combat didn't.8.6
- Batman: Arkham Origins 2013Arkham Origins gives the Joker his best scenes and Gotham too much spaceA Christmas Eve prequel with strong boss fights and a standout Joker, built on an Arkham City template that critics found bigger but not better.7.3
- Grand Theft Auto V 2013Grand Theft Auto V's heists won critics over, but Trevor split themCritics agreed on Los Santos and the heists but fought over three hard-to-like leads. Which side you take predicts how much you'll enjoy it.9.4
- Total War: Rome II 2013Rome II made Total War bigger and more political, but it launched brokenCreative Assembly's eighth Total War added hundreds of units and real factional politics, then needed a year of patches to live up to them.8.2
- Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn 2013Final Fantasy XIV wins by doing the old MMORPG formula wellCritics agreed the rebuilt Final Fantasy XIV works. They split on whether a familiar design was a flaw or the whole appeal.8.5
- Payday 2 2013Payday 2 is a brilliant heist game when the whole crew is humanCritics loved the cooperative robbery and its stealth-or-loud choices, but the AI teammates, the stealth rules and the 2015 safes drew real criticism.7.6
- Company of Heroes 2 2013Company of Heroes 2 takes squad tactics to the Eastern Front, and draws fireRelic's 2013 sequel widens the series' World War II battles to the Soviet front. Critics liked the strategy and argued over the history.7.9
- Neverwinter 2013A free Dungeons & Dragons story game for people who skip MMORPGsCritics found a friendly, story-led Forgotten Realms adventure that costs nothing to start, held back by shaky console ports and weak PvP.7.5
- Grim Dawn 2013Grim Dawn bets everything on old-school hack and slash, and mostly winsCritics agree on the score. The real argument is whether its retro, handmade design is a strength or a ceiling.8.2
- Warframe 2013Warframe makes the grind for better gear worth it through fast combatWarframe is a free-to-play loop of fighting, farming and crafting that critics call messy, and its players have kept it running since 2013.7.1
- Tomb Raider 2013Tomb Raider's 2013 reboot makes Lara earn every climb and every killCritics praised the survival reboot's bow combat, open hub island and presentation. Its story clashes with its combat, and its multiplayer fell flat.8.4
- Far Cry 3 2012Far Cry 3's island outshines the story that brings you thereCritics loved Rook Islands, its stealth and its villain Vaas, but they split on the plot and mostly wrote off the multiplayer.8.9
- Hitman: Absolution 2012Absolution gives Agent 47 tools for every hit, then narrows the mapCritics praised Hitman: Absolution's disguises and environmental kills but split over linear chapters that leave those tools less room.7.9
- XCOM: Enemy Unknown 2012Firaxis turned a 1994 alien-invasion classic into tight six-soldier tacticsXCOM: Enemy Unknown kept the dread and the dead soldiers of the original and cut away the clutter, and critics called it a modern landmark.9.0
- Resident Evil 6 2012Resident Evil 6 trades fear for firepower across four uneven campaignsCapcom's 2012 sequel is a big co-op action shooter with sharp controls and great monsters, but critics found its campaigns badly uneven.6.6
- Borderlands 2 2012Borderlands 2 keeps the loot loop and gives Pandora a villain worth chasingGearbox's 2012 sequel tunes the first game's shoot-and-loot formula rather than rebuilding it, and its sharper writing does most of the work.8.6
- Guild Wars 2 2012Guild Wars 2 cuts the grind out of the MMO and mostly gets away with itCritics in 2012 saw an online RPG built to drop the genre's level gates and chores. Most of the design keeps that promise.8.7
- Devil May Cry: HD Collection 2012Devil May Cry HD Collection still grades every fight from D to SCapcom's 2012 collection puts style on the scoreboard. Critics praised the combat, faulted the story and landed between 65 and 72 out of 100.6.9
- Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trilogy 2012Ace Attorney's first three games hold up in a collection with no extrasCapcom's compilation of its 2001 to 2004 visual novels won critics over for newcomers but offers returning fans little they haven't seen.8.2
- The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim 2011Skyrim fixed Oblivion's world and classes but kept its stiff meleeBethesda's fifth Elder Scrolls game rebuilt character growth and the map, and critics forgave its bugs and flat sword fights.9.3
- Batman: Arkham City 2011Arkham City turns a walled-off Gotham slum into a playground for BatmanCritics called Rocksteady's 2011 sequel a near-perfect take on being the Dark Knight, even if its story and villains got less praise.9.4
- The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings 2011The Witcher 2 rebuilt its combat and kept the grown-up writingCD Projekt Red's 2011 sequel added traps, thrown weapons and stealth to Geralt's toolkit, and critics rated it near the top of its year.9.0
- Terraria 2011Terraria kept changing for a decade, and critics liked it more each timeRe-Logic's 2011 sandbox didn't get replaced by a sequel. It kept getting rebuilt, and its scores went up after launch.8.2
- Portal 2 2011Portal 2 grows its portal puzzles into a funny story and a standout co-op modeCritics called Valve's 2011 sequel better than the original, though a few found it gentler, chattier and more guided than Portal.9.6
- Total War: Shogun 2 2011Shogun 2 trades the series' sprawl for a tight, punishing fight over JapanCreative Assembly's 2011 return to feudal Japan earned near-perfect scores by doing less than Empire and doing it better.9.0
- Call of Duty: Black Ops 2010Black Ops wraps the familiar Call of Duty formula in Cold War spycraftTreyarch's 2010 shooter changed less than its setting suggests, but critics still rank its campaign, multiplayer and Zombies among the series' best.8.4
- Fallout: New Vegas 2010New Vegas won near-unanimous praise and can fill 100 hoursObsidian's 2010 trip to the Mojave left critics with little to argue about. The real question is whether you have room for a game this big.8.6
- Civilization V 2010Civilization V got hexes and city defense right and its rivals wrongCritics called it the most accessible Civilization and a high point for the series, yet nearly all of them faulted computer opponents that couldn't keep up.8.8
- World of Tanks 2010World of Tanks rewards patience in 15v15 fights and a long climb up the tiersA free-to-play tank game where fights turn on armor, spotting and crew damage, and the real commitment is the slow climb to tier X.8.3
- Mount & Blade: Warband 2010Warband trades polish for a medieval sandbox you conquer on your own termsA standalone expansion that added online battles and politics to Mount & Blade, held back by dated visuals and a thin single-player story.7.3
- Napoleon: Total War 2010Napoleon's battles won critics over, but some saw only Empire underneathCritics loved the battles, but a vocal few called it Empire in new clothes, and which side you take depends on what you already own.8.4
- Left 4 Dead 2 2009Left 4 Dead 2 drew near-total praise, and nearly all of it assumed friendsValve's 2009 co-op zombie shooter split critics on almost nothing. The real divide is whether you have three other people to play it with.8.9
- Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 2009Modern Warfare 2 lives on its multiplayer and a short, loud campaignCritics called its online play a high-water mark for shooters, but the story is brief and the PC version shipped locked down.8.4
- Dragon Age: Origins 2009Critics forgave this 2009 BioWare epic its plain looks for its depthDragon Age: Origins pairs six origin stories and pausable tactical combat with visuals that critics called its weakest point.9.1
- Batman: Arkham Asylum 2009Arkham Asylum's three-button fights and Riddler hunts still set the barRocksteady's 2009 Batman game won critics with simple combat, patient stealth and Mark Hamill's Joker, though its boss fights fall flat.9.1
- The Sims 3 2009The Sims 3 opened up the whole town, and critics called it the series' bestMaxis took out the loading screens between lots and let the neighborhood live without you. Critics agreed the gamble paid off.8.9
- Plants vs. Zombies 2009PopCap's lawn defense game turned a puzzle studio's polish into strategyPlants vs. Zombies took the easy pickup of Bejeweled and Peggle into tower defense, and critics called it one of the best games of 2009.8.8
- Resident Evil 5 2009Resident Evil 5 swaps dread for co-op firefights and stiff aimCritics called it the best-looking game of its day, then faulted its stop-to-shoot controls, its turn to action and its portrayal of Africa.8.5
- Left 4 Dead 2008Left 4 Dead's AI Director makes four campaigns feel bigger than they areCritics called it near-perfect co-op and faulted its small map count. The AI Director and its team-first rules explain why the praise won.9.1
- Call of Duty: World at War 2008Treyarch's World War II return added co-op and Zombies but kept the old scriptThe fifth main Call of Duty went darker and moved to the Pacific. Critics liked the extras more than the campaign that carried them.7.8
- Command & Conquer: Red Alert 3 2008Red Alert 3 builds its whole campaign around never fighting aloneEvery story mission comes with a partner, and critics credited the co-op and multiplayer for this real-time strategy game's strong reception.8.4
- Spore 2008Spore grows a species from one cell to space, but every stage is shallowCritics loved the creature editors and huge scope of Maxis's 2008 god game, but found each of its five stages too simple to stand on its own.8.3
- Grand Theft Auto IV 2008The city is the star, and cover finally makes the gunfights workCritics called it a new open-world benchmark, while one dissenter pointed to missing features and unreliable online play.9.5
- Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare 2007Call of Duty 4 pairs a short, scripted campaign with deep multiplayerCritics loved the 2007 shooter's modern setting and online play. Where they split was the short, scripted campaign and how new any of it felt.8.8
- Portal 2007Portal ends early on purpose, and critics split on whether that was a flawValve's 2007 puzzle game drew near-universal praise, except on one point: how short it is. That one point tells you whether it's for you.9.0
- Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords 2004Obsidian's Old Republic sequel keeps the combat and darkens the storyObsidian took over BioWare's Star Wars RPG, left the fighting alone and rewrote its moral core. Critics loved the writing but not the bugs.7.9
- Final Fantasy IX 2000Final Fantasy IX looks back at the series' roots and adds a few new ideasSquare's ninth main Final Fantasy brought back the old fantasy style, added new ways to explore, and won critics over despite its slow battles.8.3
- Half-Life 1998Half-Life's brilliant Black Mesa run stumbles once it reaches XenCritics called Valve's 1998 debut one of the best shooters ever made, and most of them agreed its alien finale was the weakest part.9.6
- Final Fantasy VII 1997Final Fantasy VII bets everything on story, and critics say the bet paid offSquare's 1997 role-playing game won perfect scores for its story, its battles and its presentation. Critics flagged its translation and linear path.8.7
- Peak 2025Peak's shrinking stamina bar makes a co-op climb critics lovedA four-player climb up a mountain that changes every day, praised for its silly co-op fun and with almost no critical complaints on record.8.3
- InZOI 2025InZOI kept the Sims checklist and spent its effort on looks and toolsKrafton's life sim adds photoreal cities, a strong character creator and tools for creators, but critics found its residents strangely empty.7.5
- MiSide 2024MiSide turns a cute virtual girlfriend game into a trap you choose to openA cozy minigame routine with an anime companion becomes metafictional horror, and critics and Steam players alike were almost uniformly won over.
- Luma Island 2024Luma Island turns the farm sim into a treasure hunt with seven careersA cozy farm life sim that sends you off the farm, with hatchable creatures and careers like archaeologist driving the progress.8.0
- Path of Exile 2 2024Path of Exile 2 trades loot sprint for boss timing and chained skill combosGrinding Gear Games' sequel adds a dodge roll, twelve classes and over 100 endgame maps, and critics scored early access at 88/100.8.8
- Fields of Mistria 2024Fields of Mistria earns its Stardew comparisons with a town worth joiningA cozy farm life sim from NPC Studio that critics praised for its villagers and writing, even as some wished it borrowed less from its inspiration.9.0
- Once Human 2024Once Human splits critics over seasons that wipe your progress on a timerA free survival looter shooter that drew big crowds on Steam, though critics who liked it stopped well short of recommending it.7.5
- Wuthering Waves 2024Wuthering Waves won critics on combat and lost some on a buggy launchA free-to-play open world gacha RPG whose fast combat and generous pulls outlasted a rough first week, by most critics' accounts.7.2
- Abiotic Factor 2024Abiotic Factor turns a lab disaster into a 60-hour co-op survival gameDeep Field Games kept the scientists, the portals and the jokes, then made you build everything yourself. Critics loved it, especially with friends.8.4
- Manor Lords 2024Manor Lords grows towns without grids but leaves them little to doA one-developer medieval city-builder with real-time battles, praised for towns that follow the land and faulted for a thin early access endgame.7.3
- No Rest for the Wicked 2024A Soulslike seen from above, still in early access until March 2027Moon Studios' top-down action RPG drew a 73/100 critic average in 2024, then a 47% reading a year later. The split comes down to patience.7.3
- Deep Rock Galactic: Survivor 2024Deep Rock's top-down spin-off turns mining runs into a sharp upgrade chaseOne dwarf, a growing swarm and a trail of experience gems: a shooter modeled on Vampire Survivors that critics scored between 82/100 and 94%.8.4
- Buckshot Roulette 2023Buckshot Roulette turns a loaded shotgun into a quiet game of oddsA tabletop horror game about live shells and blanks that critics broadly agreed on, with the item system taking most of the praise.8.4
- The Finals 2023The Finals makes the arena itself the most dangerous weapon on the mapA free team shooter where players tear down, build up and walk through the map, and critics mostly loved the chaos.8.0
- Counter-Strike 2 2023Counter-Strike 2 keeps the old tension and adds smoke you can shoot throughValve's free update to Global Offensive won critics over with its gunplay and new smoke, while players were angry about what it left out at launch.8.1
- Thronefall 2023Thronefall puts the king on the battlefield, and critics barely argued about itCritics put this compact tower defense builder at 85 and 86 out of 100, and Try Hard gave it 10/10 for its fighting monarch and replay value.8.6
- Halls of Torment 2023Halls of Torment pairs Diablo's gloom with horde survival, minus stage varietyCritics called it a near-perfect blend of Diablo and Vampire Survivors, but its six stages don't differ as much as the formula deserves.8.4
- Sons of the Forest 2023Sons of the Forest is a bigger, scarier island built for friendsEndnight Games' sequel to The Forest adds a map four times larger, helpful companions and co-op for eight, though critics found the fighting thin.7.8
- Hogwarts Legacy 2023Hogwarts Legacy builds a castle worth living in and an open world that isn'tCritics loved being a student at a detailed, faithful Hogwarts. The quests, classes and launch performance around it drew more mixed reviews.6.6
- Pizza Tower 2023Pizza Tower takes Wario Land's formula and makes every level a sprint homeTour De Pizza's 2023 platformer keeps the smash-and-grab hero, drops health entirely and adds a timed escape that critics loved.9.1
- Coral Island 2022Coral Island trades Stardew's valley for a tropical reef and a diverse townCritics called this island farm sim a breath of fresh air for the genre, even as some felt it left early access before it was finished.8.5
- Dome Keeper 2022Dome Keeper turns tower defense into a race back up from the dig siteBippinbits split its 2022 roguelike between digging and defending. Critics mostly liked the mix, though some found it short and predictable.8.0
- Brotato 2022Brotato turns a potato and a between-wave shop into a smarter bullet heavenCritics praised its build-driven take on the Vampire Survivors formula and warned that runs can end fast and without much warning.7.6
- Slime Rancher 2 2022Slime Rancher 2 keeps the plort economy and adds weather worth chasingMonomi Park's direct sequel moves Beatrix LeBeau to Rainbow Island. Critics loved the loop and the look, but not the story or the late grind.7.8
- Farthest Frontier 2022Farthest Frontier is a city builder where the soil decides who survivesCritics loved its multi-year farming and hard early survival but found less to hold onto in the late game.8.1
- PlateUp! 2022A co-op kitchen rebuilt as a 15-day roguelite run that friends plan togetherCritics found a calm, strategic co-op kitchen under clunky controls and a cluttered screen, with a structure built for one more run.7.3
- Dread Hunger 2022Dread Hunger sold over a million copies while critics settled on a shrugA social deception survival game for Windows that drew big player numbers but only mixed or average reviews from critics.7.0
- Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel 2022Master Duel puts the full Yu-Gi-Oh card game on eight platforms for freeKonami's free-to-play card game drew huge crowds and favorable reviews, but its separate card pool and its earnings model are worth knowing first.7.8
- Icarus 2021Icarus puts a clock on every survival run and wipes your base when it endsA 69/100 and a later 31% from the same critic count fit a survival game built on timed drops that erase everything you build.6.9
- Wartales 2021Wartales turns a broke mercenary band into a deep tactics sandboxCritics praised Wartales for its party building and the stories its systems create, but some found it plain to look at and repetitive late on.7.7
- Escape Simulator 2021Escape Simulator is at its best when friends crowd into the same roomCritics agreed Pine Studio's escape rooms are fun. They split on how fun, and the answer seems to depend on whether you bring friends.7.7
- eFootball 2021eFootball's pitch finally looks good, but the football still doesn'tKonami's free successor to Pro Evolution Soccer launched to record-low scores, and its 1.0 update fixed the looks far more than the football.3.1
- Medieval Dynasty 2021Medieval Dynasty turns firewood and heirs into a slow, absorbing village lifeA first-person survival builder where the chores are the point, held back by thin quests and menus that explain too little.7.4
- Potion Craft 2021Potion Craft turns brewing into map reading, and critics loved itA cozy alchemy shop sim whose crafting system drew some of the warmest praise critics have given any crafting game.8.3
- Timberborn 2021Timberborn makes water the hardest and best part of building a beaver cityCritics praise its dams, droughts and deep water simulation, but newcomers should expect a steep first stretch before the systems click.8.6
- Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodhunt 2021Bloodhunt put vampire powers on a battle royale, then shut its servers downCritics found Sharkmob's free-to-play vampire shooter promising and odd in equal measure. Since April 28, 2026, nobody can play it.7.7
- The Last Spell 2021Three heroes against hundreds of undead, and the imbalance is the pointThe Last Spell turns a hopeless siege into a turn-based puzzle where daytime building decides whether the magic circle survives the night.8.1
- Going Medieval 2021Going Medieval turns a plague-emptied Britain into a colony you dig intoA colony sim set in an alternate 14th century Britain, with hands-off settlers, voxel building and raids that grow with you. Critics broadly recommend it.7.8
- Valheim 2021Valheim rewards friends who like to build, explore and work things out unguidedA Viking survival game with up to ten players, eight bosses and very little hand-holding, and critics loved it from its first early access days.9.0
- Omori 2020Omori makes emotions the status effects in a game about anxietyA dark, dreamlike role-playing game that critics loved for its writing and art, even when they disagreed about whether its battles pull their weight.8.6
- Phasmophobia 2020Phasmophobia is a ghost hunt built for four friends and one open microphoneKinetic Games' co-op ghost hunt won critics over with its sound and scares, but its shaky animations and repetitive contracts still drew complaints.7.8
- Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020Microsoft Flight Simulator makes the whole planet the reason to take offCritics called Asobo Studio's 2020 reboot the best-looking flight sim yet, and its helper tools mean newcomers can get a plane off the ground.9.1
- Library of Ruina 2020Library of Ruina is a dense card battler whose interface works against itProjectMoon's sequel to Lobotomy Corporation won praise for its music, story and deep combat, but its menus and console ports drew complaints.7.0
- Gunfire Reborn 2020Gunfire Reborn turns shooting gallery rooms into a co-op roguelite loopA first-person roguelite where coins, scrolls and random weapon drops reshape every run, and critics found the formula hard to put down.7.7
- Black Mesa 2020Black Mesa rebuilds Half-Life for players who want the 1998 classic to feel newA fan remake that Valve approved for sale, with a reworked Xen finale that critics called the biggest improvement over the original.8.4
- Transport Fever 2 2019Transport Fever 2 lets trains, trams and ferries reshape a map from 1850 onCritics liked its city-building payoff and its history-spanning vehicle roster, even where they found it lacked depth.7.6
- Trailmakers 2019Trailmakers earned a decent average from critics but few outright endorsementsA physics-driven vehicle builder that critics scored 69/100 on average, while the same five reviews produced a far colder 20%.6.9
- Oxygen Not Included 2019Oxygen Not Included rewards patient engineers and leaves newcomers to sinkKlei's colony sim drew praise for its design and science and worry over how steep it gets, with an 80/100 critic score from two reviews.8.0
- Muse Dash 2019Muse Dash wins critics over with two buttons, cute Muses and a sweet soundtrackA rhythm game that critics found simple and charming, though its aggregate scores land in mixed territory rather than acclaim.7.5
- Days Gone 2019Days Gone's hordes are thrilling, but the road between them runs longBend Studio's open-world zombie ride has some of the tensest fights critics saw, padded out by repetitive side work and a thirsty motorcycle.6.7
- Workers & Resources: Soviet Republic 2019Soviet Republic is a logistics puzzle first and a city-builder secondA deep, demanding planner's sim that critics mostly liked, with a slow start that early reviewers flagged and later tutorials set out to fix.
- Super Animal Royale 2018Super Animal Royale shrinks the battle royale to a top-down, 64-animal brawlA 2D overhead take on the last-one-standing shooter, with players who love it and critics who rated it lower.7.0
- Kenshi 2018Kenshi rewards patience with a huge, reactive world and punishes it with grindCritics praised Kenshi's size and depth but split on its grind and clumsy squad controls. That split tells you whether it's for you.7.6
- X4: Foundations 2018X4 builds a galaxy that runs without you, but critics stayed lukewarmEgosoft's 2018 space sim runs trade, war and piracy without you. Critics called it a clear step up from X Rebirth but stopped short of praise.6.8
- Red Dead Redemption 2 2018Red Dead Redemption 2 builds a peerless frontier with a few heavy flawsCritics ranked Rockstar's 1899 outlaw epic among the best games ever made, while faulting its controls, its slow start and its Native American characters.9.3
- Gwent: The Witcher Card Game 2018Gwent turns a Witcher side game into a two-row battle of pointsCD Projekt's free card game rests on one sum: more power on the board wins the round, and two rounds win the match.8.4
- Warhammer 40,000: Gladius – Relics of War 2018Gladius is a 4X game with the talking taken out, and only war leftProxy Studios removed diplomacy from the 4X formula. Critics found a solid 40K wargame, but some found it slow and easy to predict.7.2
- House Flipper 2018House Flipper makes scrubbing a filthy house feel good, for a whileCritics loved turning grimy homes into sellable ones in this 2018 renovation sim, but most doubted the fun lasts past the first few flips.6.8
- The Forest 2018The Forest's cannibals watch, adapt and remember how you treated themA 2018 survival horror game where crafting keeps you alive by day and a tribe that reacts to your choices decides how bad the nights get.8.2
- Neverwinter Nights: Enhanced Edition 2018Neverwinter Nights gives you the tools to run D&D but a thin storyBeamdog's 2018 edition of BioWare's D&D game keeps its faithful 3rd Edition rules and admired toolset, wrapped around a campaign critics shrugged at.6.0
- Surviving Mars 2018Surviving Mars makes a dome colony that can actually die, and that's the appealHaemimont's 2018 Mars city builder trades cash for real resources and lets bad calls end your colony. Critics liked it, with some caveats.7.8
- Z1 Battle Royale 2018Z1 Battle Royale beat its rivals to the genre and then lost its crowdA huge-lobby scavenge-and-survive shooter with crafting and vehicles, held back by bugs, server outages and a shrinking player base.7.0
- Celeste 2018Celeste keeps the brutal jumps and adds a way for anyone to reach the topMaddy Makes Games' 2018 climb pairs some of the most praised controls in platforming with a story about anxiety and a difficulty setting critics loved.9.2
- SCP: Secret Laboratory 2017Secret Laboratory is only as good as the strangers you spawn withA free, round-based horror shooter that critics scored anywhere from 57.4/100 to five stars, depending on how much chaos they could stand.5.7
- Doki Doki Literature Club! 2017DDLC hides a horror game inside a cheerful dating simTeam Salvato's 2017 visual novel plays sweet first so that its file-breaking turn hits harder, and most critics say the trick lands.8.7
- DJMax Respect 2017DJMax Respect scored 87 with critics, but on PC and Xbox it won't play offlineNeowiz's DJMax series entry drew strong reviews on PS4, while its later PC and Xbox versions need an internet connection even for solo play.8.7
- Escape from Tarkov 2017Escape from Tarkov makes every extraction count and every death cost youA hardcore extraction shooter for players who want real stakes, and a hard sell for anyone who hates losing their gear.7.8
- Albion Online 2017Albion Online makes players craft every sword, then lets them lose it on deathA free, classless sandbox MMORPG where gear defines your role, players build the whole economy and the riskiest zones take everything you carry.7.9
- Rising Storm 2: Vietnam 2017Rising Storm 2 makes 64 players fight the Vietnam War on unequal termsA tactical multiplayer shooter where teamwork beats solo skill and the North and South don't play alike. Critics rated it generally favorable.7.9
- Crossout 2017In Crossout you build a war machine from parts, then watch them get shot offA free-to-play vehicular combat game where the garage matters as much as the fight, and where the store sits close to the parts you want.6.1
- Forts 2017Forts turns your base into a building that can be knocked downA 2D strategy game where the fort you build is also your weak point, and critics never settled on how well that idea holds up.7.2
- Hollow Knight 2017Hollow Knight earns its brutal bosses with a kingdom worth getting lost inTeam Cherry's 2017 Metroidvania won near-universal praise for its combat and charms, and some critics called it unfair along the way.8.8
- NieR: Automata 2017A story critics ranked among the best ever, with combat that split themPlatinumGames' 2017 action RPG earned perfect scores for its story, and critics who wanted deeper combat and a cleaner PC port still had complaints.8.6
- World of Tanks Blitz 2016World of Tanks Blitz puts detailed free tank battles on phones, PCs and SwitchCritics praised the detail and depth of Wargaming's free-to-play tank shooter, and warned that it's hard to learn and asks players to keep investing time.8.4
- Battlefield 1 2016Battlefield 1 trades modern rifles for trench clubs, horses and zeppelinsDICE's First World War shooter gave critics a fresh setting and a strong 64-player game, with a short campaign told only from the Allied Powers' side.9.1
- Cossacks 3 2016Cossacks 3 rebuilds the 2000 original faithfully and adds very little to itGSC Game World's remake brings back the 12 nations and huge armies of Cossacks: European Wars, and critics found too little that was new.6.5
- No Man's Sky 2016No Man's Sky rewards the wanderer and tests anyone who needs a reason to land18 quintillion planets for the player who wants to drift, and a survival loop that critics found thin once the novelty wore off.6.7
- Turmoil 2016Turmoil turns the oil rush into a tight loop that wears thin with repetitionA simple 19th-century oil drilling sim that critics called addictive, and also repetitive once you've seen a few campaign years.7.2
- Factorio 2016Critics only argued about how much to love Factorio, and that says who it's forA factory game with plain graphics and a ruinous pull, scored between 82 and 92 by critics. The narrow spread is the useful part.8.3
- World of Warships 2015World of Warships rewards patient captains who like slow naval fightsA free-to-play naval shooter built around teamwork and a long ladder of historical ships, at its best in player-versus-player battles.8.2
- Trove 2015Trove turns every portal into a loot hunt with the payoff color-codedTrion Worlds' voxel sandbox MMO builds everything around portals, gear drops and an account-wide collection. Critics landed it near 70.6.8
- Fallout Shelter 2015Fallout Shelter's money question splits critics more than its vault doesA free vault-building sim that critics found charming and easy to like, and split hard on its cash shop and its lack of long-term goals.7.0
- Clicker Heroes 2015Clicker Heroes built on Cloudstone's art and opened Steam to idle gamesPlaysaurus's spinoff turns one click into a long reset-and-repeat loop. Critics called it addictive, but the counted scores average 57/100.5.7
- Brawlhalla 2014Brawlhalla wins on movement and price, not on tight designA free platform fighter with 70 Legends and full cross-play that critics enjoyed playing but ranked below the genre's best.6.8
- Men of War: Assault Squad 2 2014Assault Squad 2 kept the series' hard edge, and critics rated it middlingDigitalmindsoft's 2014 follow-up to Men of War: Assault Squad drew mixed scores, but its difficulty won it a warmer review from PC Gamer US.6.9
- Banished 2014Banished is a harsh survival sim that turns into a calm town plannerCritics loved the hungry early winters of this 2014 city builder but split on what's left once the town is safe.7.3
- DayZ 2013DayZ's brutal survival sandbox won awards and players but not criticsA deep, unforgiving zombie survival game with millions of buyers and a critic aggregate that slid to 25% by 2024.4.1
- Path of Exile 2013Path of Exile buries a brilliant build system under very little guidanceCritics loved the depth of Grinding Gear Games' free-to-play action RPG and warned that it does almost nothing to teach it.8.0
- Space Engineers 2013Space Engineers hands you a welder and no finish lineA voxel sandbox where you build working ships and stations block by block, and where every goal is one you set yourself.
- Rocksmith 2014 2013Rocksmith 2014 swaps the plastic controller for a real guitarCritics called it a big step up from the 2011 original and more of a teacher, though it needs a real instrument, a cable and money for songs.8.4
- ARMA 3 2013Arma 3 rewards patient tacticians and punishes everyone elseA huge, deadly military sandbox that critics praised for its realism and its islands, and faulted for a brutal learning curve.7.3
- Europa Universalis IV 2013Europa Universalis IV rewards players who'll learn its systems the hard wayCritics loved the depth and the improvements over Europa Universalis III, but the tutorials, combat and bugs drew the most complaints.8.8
- Papers, Please 2013Papers, Please makes a border desk job feel like a moral trapLucas Pope's 1982 checkpoint sim won critics over with dread and hard choices, though some found the paperwork itself a slog.8.8
- Cookie Clicker 2013Cookie Clicker began as one big cookie and turned into something much strangerJulien Thiennot's 2013 browser game is the idle game IGN called the genre's greatest, and it still asks whether all that growth means anything.
- Dota 2 2013Dota 2's depth wins critics over, but its learning cliff splits themValve's five-on-five MOBA earned near-universal praise for depth and fairness, along with steady warnings about its learning curve and its players.9.1
- Don't Starve 2013Don't Starve rewards patient players and punishes everyone elseKlei's 2013 survival game won critics over with its art and its many ways to die, but permadeath makes every restart a slog.8.1
- Baldur's Gate: Enhanced Edition 2012Baldur's Gate kept almost exactly as it was in 1998, with a fresh coat on topBeamdog's 2012 remaster keeps the original rules and adds new kits, companions and an arena. Critics mostly liked it, and the old framework shows.7.7
- PlanetSide 2 2012PlanetSide 2 runs 2,000-player wars for free, and that's the argumentCritics loved the scale of PlanetSide 2's battles. They split over its free-to-play grind, its prices and its bugs.7.8
- War Thunder 2012Gaijin's flight sims grew into a free-to-play war on land, sea and airWar Thunder took Gaijin's air combat roots, added tanks and ships, and kept growing for over a decade. Critics have cooled since.7.8
- MechWarrior Online 2012MechWarrior Online rewards patient mech pilots and leaves newcomers lostA free-to-play BattleTech shooter where careful aim and team tactics matter, held back by a steep learning curve and thin early variety.7.8
- Hotline Miami 2012Hotline Miami kills you in one hit, then hands the level right backA 1989 top-down shooter where every enemy and the player die in one blow, and the fast restart makes the brutality hard to put down.8.2
- FTL: Faster Than Light 2012FTL turns a starship captain fantasy into short, punishing runs worth repeatingSubset Games' 2012 roguelike won over critics with tense ship management and permadeath, though some found its difficulty cruel.8.8
- Phantasy Star Online 2 2012Phantasy Star Online 2 rewards class tinkerers more than its cash shop doesSega's free-to-play online action RPG gives build-minded co-op players plenty to work with, but critics flagged the microtransactions.7.4
- Persona 4: Golden 2012Persona 4 Golden turns a year of rainy days into an RPG deadlineCritics praised the small-town murder mystery and its calendar of friendships, while flagging a plot that sometimes makes you wait.9.1
- The Walking Dead: Season One 2012A zombie game that's really about keeping one girl aliveTelltale's 2012 adventure trades action for hard, murky choices, and critics said the bond between Lee and Clementine carries all five episodes.6.5
- Crusader Kings II 2012Crusader Kings II makes a family tree the deadliest weapon in medieval EuropeA grand strategy game where you rule a bloodline, not a country, and a bad marriage can hurt you for generations.8.7
- Star Wars: The Old Republic 2011The Old Republic puts a voiced BioWare story game inside an MMOCritics loved the voiced class stories and companions, but the familiar online grind around them drew most of the complaints.8.5
- DC Universe Online 2011DC Universe Online lets comics fans build a hero who stands beside BatmanA free-to-play MMO with a deep character creator and stories drawn from DC's comics, held back by a familiar grind and middling critic scores.7.4
- Victoria II 2010Victoria II models a century of markets better than it explains themParadox's 1836 to 1936 grand strategy game earned praise for its depth and doubts about whether that depth adds up to play.7.5
- Star Trek Online 2010Star Trek Online's ship combat carries a game critics still can't agree onCritics have called it both the best and the worst Star Trek game. Its space battles explain most of that split.6.8
- Empire: Total War 2009A vast 18th-century war map held back by an unreliable AI opponentCritics loved the campaign's scale and the gunpowder land battles, but the computer opponent and the naval controls drew repeated complaints.9.2
- The Witcher: Enhanced Edition 2008The Witcher makes your choices come due acts later, not scenes laterCD Projekt RED's Witcher puts delayed consequences and lesser evils at the center, and critics rewarded the patience it asks for.8.6
- Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War – Soulstorm 2008Soulstorm adds fliers and two factions but plays Dark Crusade's campaign againThe third Dawn of War expansion brings the Sisters of Battle, the Dark Eldar and an air unit for every army, on a campaign critics found familiar.7.0
- Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance 2007Forged Alliance adds a fourth faction and keeps what critics likedThe stand-alone Supreme Commander expansion brings the Seraphim, orbital weapons and a better interface, and critics rated it as highly as the original.8.3
- Team Fortress 2 2007Team Fortress 2 turned a 1996 Quake mod into nine classes and a free shooterValve's 2007 sequel kept the old class-based core and added stats, item drops, and over 100 maps. Critics scored it at or near the top.9.0
- Medieval II: Total War 2006Medieval II polishes Rome's formula instead of reinventing itCritics agreed the battles and campaign were superb. They disagreed on whether a careful refinement of the series deserved full marks.8.6
- Microsoft Flight Simulator X 2006Flight Simulator X rewards patient pilots but strained the PCs of 2006Critics praised its realism and detail and gave it top simulation awards, but its framerate pushed the computers of its day too hard.8.6
- The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion 2006Oblivion lets you go anywhere in Cyrodiil, and critics forgave its seams for itBethesda's 2006 open-world role-playing game won critics over with freedom and a lived-in world, despite level scaling, loading stutters and stiff dialogue.9.3
- Star Wars: Empire at War 2006Empire at War makes you win the fight before the shooting startsPetroglyph's 2006 Star Wars strategy game pairs thrilling space battles with ground fights that critics found repetitive.7.8
- Civilization IV 2005Civilization IV rewards the patient empire builder and stumbles mainly onlineFiraxis's 2005 turn-based epic won over critics with sharper AI and five ways to win. The rough edges sit mostly in its online lobby.8.8
- Resident Evil 4 2005Resident Evil 4 moved the camera behind Leon and made every shot countCapcom's 2005 rescue mission in rural Spain traded the series' slow, fixed-angle horror for aimed, physical combat, and critics called it a classic.8.9
- Half-Life 2 2004Half-Life 2 turns crates, saw blades and grenades into your best weaponsValve's 2004 shooter built its fights around a physics gun, and critics still rank it among the best games ever made.9.4
- Counter-Strike: Source 2004Valve's Source remake of Counter-Strike kept the rules and sharpened the lookValve and Turtle Rock Studios moved Counter-Strike to the Source engine in 2004, and critics praised the sharper look over the familiar rounds.8.8
- Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas 2004San Andreas built a whole state, then made you drive across itCritics hailed its world and story as console gaming at its peak, while faulting long mission drives and how it handles race.9.6
- Rome: Total War 2004Rome's family tree runs the war in Creative Assembly's 2004 strategy classicTurn-based empire building meets real-time battles, and critics in 2004 called the result one of the best strategy games ever made.8.0
- Rise of Nations 2003Rise of Nations brings Civilization's borders and ages into real timeBig Huge Games' 2003 strategy game adds territory, attrition and eight ages of history to a fast RTS, and critics still rank it among the best.8.6
- EVE Online 2003EVE Online hands one shared galaxy to players and lets them fight over itA 2003 space MMO that critics warmed to slowly, built for players who want their choices to matter to thousands of other people.8.2
- Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2003Knights of the Old Republic still rewards players who'd rather talk than swingBioWare's 2003 Star Wars RPG pairs tabletop dice rules with a story critics crowned, but its pace and side games won't suit everyone.8.6
- Stronghold: Crusader 2002Crusader moved Stronghold to the desert and made farmland worth fighting forFirefly Studios' 2002 sequel kept the first Stronghold's economy, then added a skirmish mode and a 50-level trail that gave it a long life.8.6
- The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind 2002Morrowind traded Daggerfall's generic world for one striking islandThe third Elder Scrolls kept its learn-by-doing skill system, set itself on a volcanic island, and left critics fighting its journal.9.0
- Civilization III 2001Civilization III kept the Civ II formula and added small wonders on topThe first Civilization not designed by Sid Meier won strategy awards in 2001, despite a buggy launch that patches had to fix.
- Counter-Strike 1999Counter-Strike rewards the team that talks, not the lone gunmanValve's 1999 tactical shooter is built on one rule critics kept coming back to: a coordinated team beats a skilled solo player.8.8
- EverQuest 1999EverQuest earned its legend through cooperation, not its combatCritics called the 1999 MMORPG an online killer app, and they also called its fights boring and its first levels unforgiving.